Mortgage Forbearance vs. Loan Modification: Which Is Right for You During the Coronavirus Pandemic?
The coronavirus crisis has generated record-breaking unemployment claims since March for more than 42.6 million American workers as of this writing — and that’s making it hard for affected homeowners to afford their mortgage payments.
Figuring out whether mortgage forbearance or modification is right for you can be overwhelming during a financial hardship. A mortgage forbearance agreement temporarily pauses your monthly payments and a loan modification permanently changes the terms of your loan to make your payments more affordable.
Homeowners who are already behind on their mortgage payments may find relief from a modification, while those looking for help before a late payment may be better served requesting a forbearance.
Understanding mortgage forbearance vs. loan modification
A mortgage forbearance is a temporary pause in mortgage payments approved by your lender. The lender agrees in advance to allow you to stop making payments, or make a reduced payment.
The Coronavirus Aid, Relief and Economic Security (CARES) Act includes mortgage relief programs that allow you to request a 180-day forbearance, followed by one 180-day extension if you need it.
In other words, borrowers with federally backed loans have the option to request forbearance for up to 12 months — also known as a forbearance period. During this time, your credit isn’t negatively impacted by not making payments, and the foreclosure process is halted. Repayment doesn’t begin until the forbearance period ends.
Who it’s best for:
Mortgage forbearance can be the best option if you’re on the verge of falling behind and need a break from payments to make adjustments to your finances. A forbearance is ideal for people experiencing a temporary, short-term hardship, but it’s not a permanent solution, said Sara Singhas, director of loan administration with the Mortgage Bankers Association (MBA).
On the other hand, a loan modification changes the original terms of your loan permanently. Those changes might include extending your repayment term or lowering your interest rate, for example. You either have to be in jeopardy of falling behind or already in default on your mortgage to qualify for a loan modification.
A loan modification typically won’t affect your credit profile, but any late payments (30 days behind or more) leading up to, and possibly during, the modification will. Your credit score could drop by a range of 60 to 130 points, depending on where it stood before your missed mortgage payments, according to research from FICO.
Who it’s best for:
If you’re already in default, a mortgage modification may work better for you. Some lenders require that you be in “imminent default,” meaning you’re already past-due on payments or expect to be within a certain time frame, to request a loan modification.
|Key Differences Between a Mortgage Forbearance vs. a Loan Modification|
|Mortgage forbearance||Mortgage modification|
|Temporary payment relief||Permanent payment relief|
|Missed payments are not reported to credit bureaus||Missed payments before or during a modification may be reported to credit bureaus|
|Financial documentation to prove hardship is not required||Financial documentation proving hardship may need to be provided|
|Payments can be paused up to 12 months for federally backed loans||Must continue to make monthly mortgage payments|
|The foreclosure process is halted during the forbearance period||There’s a foreclosure risk if additional payments are missed|
|A lump sum may be due for the missed payments at the end of the forbearance period||No lump-sum payments|
|Terms of the original loan remain the same||Changes your original loan terms|
How forbearance requests are affecting the mortgage process
As of June 2, 4.73 million homeowners — or nearly 9% of all mortgages in the country — were in a forbearance plan due to the COVID-19 pandemic, according to research from Black Knight, a data analytics firm. These homeowners have $1 trillion in unpaid mortgage principal and include 7.1% of all loans backed by Fannie Mae or Freddie Mac and 12.3% of government-insured FHA and VA loans.
Changes to the mortgage process are already being made that affect current and future homeowners’ prospects for getting a loan. Here’s what to look out for:
Locking in rates may be tougher. Some lenders have eliminated the ability to lock in a mortgage rate until the loan is approved, said Rocke Andrews, president of the National Association of Mortgage Brokers (NAMB). In other words, keep shopping with lenders until you nail down a preapproval and lock in your rate, Andrews added.
Qualifying for government-backed loans may be harder.As lenders deal with a wave of forbearance requests, investors have less of an appetite for risk, leading many mortgage companies to increase minimum scores for government-backed loans to 620 — or even as high as 740, Andrews explained. Loans backed by the Federal Housing Administration (FHA) and, to a lesser extent, the Department of Veterans Affairs (VA), typically have less-stringent qualifying standards than conventional loans. Those lenient standards may be the reason why a higher share of FHA and VA loan borrowers are requesting forbearance help, as the Black Knight data above show.
Finding certain mortgage products may be more challenging. Non-qualified mortgages, or non-QM for short, provide alternative lending options for borrowers with poor credit or complex income profiles, and who typically can’t qualify with traditional loan programs. In the current environment, non-QM loans are virtually nonexistent, Andrews said. Borrowers seeking jumbo loans, or mortgages over the conforming loan limit of $510,400 in most areas, also have fewer lenders to choose from, Andrews added. And in some cases, lenders are doing away with home equity products.
Homeowners face varying outcomes when seeking relief
While some homeowners are having trouble receiving mortgage assistance from their lender, David Whitehair, a homeowner in Columbia, S.C., said he had a straightforward experience getting relief.
Whitehair, 29, is a general manager for a local restaurant that’s been shuttered for a month now. The business attempted the takeout-only approach before closing its doors.
“We tried it for that initial week, and it cost more money to run the business opening than we were bringing in,” Whitehair said.
Whitehair and his wife own two rental properties along with their primary residence. When a payment was coming due on a mortgage for one of the rental properties, his banker called to ask if he was ready to pay. Whitehair made the payment, then his banker surprisingly offered help.
“He asked if there was anything he could do for us; I asked if there was any way we could push the payments back,” he said.
His lender was offering three months of mortgage forbearance, with the option of either paying a lump sum or adding the amount owed to the outstanding balance when the forbearance ends. He chose the latter and submitted the necessary paperwork.
What to do if you don’t have a federally backed mortgage
As previously mentioned, the mortgage relief programs in the CARES Act only covers homeowners with federally backed mortgages. But what if you don’t have an agency-backed loan? After all, just under a third of mortgages fall into this category.
For non-agency loans, it’s really up to the investor or servicer on a case-by-case basis in terms of what is offered, Singhas said.
“They (borrowers) still can apply for forbearance and many servicers are granting those pretty routinely right now,” said Sarah Bolling Mancini, an attorney at the National Consumer Law Center. “It’s just not mandatory under federal law.”
Future legislation may change this, but the best thing to do — regardless of whether you have a federally backed mortgage — is to reach out to your servicer directly if your income has been impacted by the coronavirus pandemic and you’re concerned about satisfying your forthcoming mortgage payments, Mancini said.
What to do if you still need help after your forbearance period ends
If you haven’t fully recovered financially at the end of your forbearance period, you may be eligible for an extension, provided you weren’t already granted one. It’s important to be proactive when you initially seek mortgage relief so you’re clear on what happens after you’ve received help.
“When you start out the forbearance, you’re not guaranteed anything,” Mancini explained. “You have to ask your servicer what the options are going to be and you have to communicate with the servicer before the forbearance ends.”
Options for repayment after your forbearance ends may change as the mortgage industry works to find ways to help homeowners. The standard repayment options for making up the balance of missed payments during the forbearance period include:
Lump-sum reinstatement payment
The entire balance of paused payments is due with this option. Although it requires the biggest cash outlay, it also brings you current without increasing your loan balance or adding to your monthly payment.
If you were able to pay a portion of your payment during your forbearance period, you may be able to pay back just the missed payment balance or have your payment increased for a set period of time until the past-due balance is paid off.
If you can’t quite afford your original mortgage payments once your forbearance period is over but can pay a reduced amount, consider applying for a loan modification with your lender or servicer. Expect a trial repayment period for the first few months to demonstrate your ability to afford the lower monthly payments.
Most investors are offering to bundle all the missed payments and make them non-interest bearing, said Sapan Bafna, vice president of advanced delivery engines with CoreLogic. The payment doesn’t go up, and the borrower doesn’t have to worry about the additional payments until they sell or refinance their home, Bafna added. Some loan programs, like FHA, may not permit payment deferrals. In that case, a loan modification is the only option, Bafna said.
Some conventional lenders will begin offering a special payment deferral program on July 1 to homeowners — with Fannie Mae or Freddie Mac-owned loans — who are financially impacted by the coronavirus pandemic. The program allows them to resume their regular monthly mortgage payments after forbearance, and add the previously missed payments to the end of their loan repayment term.
Ellie Pepper, relationship and innovations director with the National Housing Resource Center, advises homeowners to also be mindful of their escrow account, as property taxes and homeowners insurance premiums still need to be paid as they come due.
“It’s possible that your lender will pay them on your behalf, but then you’ll have to pay back your lender,” Pepper explained. “So if you have an escrow account you’ll have a shortage, and that will have to be paid back as well.”