Best Colorado Homeowners Insurance for 2026

Auto-Owners has the best home insurance overall, but Allstate may be cheaper.

How Does LendingTree Get Paid?
Key takeaways
  • Auto-Owners is the best homeowners insurance company for most people in Colorado thanks to its strong customer satisfaction ratings, competitive premiums and flexible coverage options.
  • The average cost of homeowners insurance in Colorado is $4,717 per year, or about $393 per month.
  • Colorado homeowners face elevated risks from hailstorms, wildfires and severe weather claims. 

Best homeowners insurance in Colorado

The best homeowners insurance companies in Colorado have different strengths, with some offering cheap rates and others providing broader coverage options or better customer satisfaction. Colorado homeowners can face elevated risks from hailstorms, wind damage and wildfires, which makes getting a policy with the right features especially important.

Best overall homeowners insurance in Colorado : Auto-Owners

Auto-Owners logo

Average annual rate: $2,372

4-Stars

Why we chose it: Auto-Owners combines strong customer satisfaction ratings with competitive pricing for Colorado homeowners. The insurer also offers several useful optional add-ons, including guaranteed replacement cost and water and sewage backup coverage. The company also works through independent agents, who can offer personalized help to homeowners as they compare coverage options.

Who it’s best for: Homeowners who want dependable customer service, affordable rates and strong policy customization options.

PROS

  • Strong customer satisfaction and claims reputation
  • Several useful optional coverages available
  • Independent agents provide personalized support

CONS

  • No online quotes or claims process
  • Not the cheapest rates in the state

Best cheap home insurance in CO : Allstate

Allstate

Average annual rate: $1,879

4-Stars

Why we chose it: To start, Allstate offers the lowest average home insurance rate among the companies on our list. But then the insurer also provides several discounts that can lower coverage costs even more. Plus, it doesn’t skimp on optional coverage add-ons, which may be appealing to Colorado homeowners who want to keep their costs as low as possible without losing some flexible policy features. 

Who it’s best for: Colorado homeowners looking for affordable coverage along with the option of multiple add-ons and discount opportunities.

PROS

  • Lowest average rates in the state
  • Several discounts for bundling and smart devices
  • Wide range of optional coverage add-ons

CONS

  • Higher-than-average number of customer complaints
  • Coverage options vary by location

Best for customer service : Shelter Insurance

Shelter

Average annual rate: $3,403

4.5 Stars

Why we chose it: Shelter earned the highest LendingTree star rating among the insurers on our list, reflecting strong customer satisfaction and ease of use. The company also relies on local agents who can help homeowners customize policies and navigate claims more easily. 

Who it’s best for: Homeowners who value personalized support and are willing to pay a little more for strong customer service.

PROS

  • Highest star rating among listed insurers
  • Roughly half as many customer complaints as other companies its size
  • Local agents provide personalized guidance

CONS

  • Average premiums run higher than cheaper competitors
  • Mobile app doesn’t get the best ratings

Compare Colorado home insurance rates and ratings

CompanyAnnual rate*LendingTree rating Complaint rating*
Allstate$1,8794-Stars
4/5
1.2
State Farm$2,2084-Stars
4/5
1.4
Auto-Owners$2,3724-Stars
4/5
0.5
Farm Bureau$2,6783.5-Stars
3.5/5
0.6
Shelter$3,4034.5-Stars
4.5/5
0.4
USAA*$3,7494-Stars
4/5
0.5
Nationwide$4,1363.5-Stars
3.5/5
1.2
American Family$4,1954-Stars
4/5
0.4
*Premiums are a statewide average based on $400,000 of coverage. Complaint ratings are from the National Association of Insurance Commissioners (NAIC), based on the 2025 complaint index. A lower score is better. A score of 1.0 is average for a company of that size. USAA is only available to current and former members of the military and eligible family members.

Home insurance rates in Colorado can vary widely between insurers. Comparing quotes from multiple companies may help you find lower premiums, stronger coverage options and better discounts.

LendingTree analyzed home insurance quotes from every Colorado ZIP code to identify the best options for you.

Our team evaluated pricing, customer experience, financial reliability and coverage features to determine the top home insurance companies in your state.

See our full methodology.

How much is homeowners insurance in Colorado?

co-home-26

The average cost of homeowners insurance in Colorado is $4,717 per year, or about $393 per month.

Colorado homeowners often pay higher premiums because insurers face elevated risks from hailstorms, wildfires and severe wind damage across the state.

Rates can also vary widely depending on where you live, your home’s age and the amount of dwelling coverage you choose. Comparing quotes from multiple insurers can help you find the most affordable premium and best coverage options for you.

Average home insurance rates by dwelling coverage amount

Home insurance rates in Colorado usually increase as your dwelling coverage limits rise.

Company$300,000$400,000$550,000$750,000
Allstate$1,784$1,879$2,030$3,002
Auto-Owners$1,911$2,372$2,572$3,763
Shelter$2,587$3,403$4,490$6,956
State average$3,889$4,717$5,847$7,234

Colorado home insurance rates by city

Home insurance rates can vary widely across Colorado depending on local weather risks, rebuilding costs and claim trends. Fruitvale and Grand Junction have the lowest average premiums in the state at $1,933 and $1,954 per year, respectively. 

Both cities sit on Colorado’s Western Slope, where homeowners generally face less severe hail exposure than many communities along the Front Range and High Plains. 

Holyoke and Burlington have the highest average home insurance premiums in Colorado at $6,356 and $6,360 per year, respectively. Both communities sit in eastern Colorado near the High Plains region, where hail can cause significant property damage, which then drives up insurance rates. 

Hailstorms in the High Plains and in the higher elevations of Colorado’s nearby Front Range are typically denser than anywhere else in the country, according to the Insurance Institute for Business & Home Safety, which is why they can cause so much more damage.

CityAverage rate
Acres Green$5,345
Agate$5,729
Aguilar$4,269
Air Force Academy$5,282
Akron$6,012
Alamosa$2,371
Alamosa East$2,366
Allenspark$4,554
Alma$3,223
Almont$2,249
Amherst$6,169
Anton$5,863
Antonito$2,389
Applewood$4,980
Arapahoe$6,007
Arlington$5,651
Arriba$5,631
Arvada$4,966
Aspen$2,199
Atwood$5,723
Ault$4,720
Aurora$5,199
Austin$2,095
Avon$2,196
Avondale$5,439
Bailey$4,037
Basalt$2,196
Battlement Mesa$2,151
Bayfield$2,262
Bedrock$2,332
Bellvue$4,264
Bennett$5,446
Berkley$4,957
Berthoud$4,254
Bethune$6,104
Beulah$5,121
Black Forest$5,759
Black Hawk$4,180
Blanca$2,779
Blende$5,479
Blue River$2,533
Boncarbo$4,182
Bond$2,384
Boone$5,441
Boulder$4,554
Bow Mar$4,921
Branson$4,905
Breckenridge$2,514
Briggsdale$5,196
Brighton$4,988
Brookside$3,623
Broomfield$4,556
Brush$5,962
Buena Vista$2,336
Buffalo Creek$4,785
Burlington$6,360
Burns$2,682
Byers$5,911
Cahone$2,294
Calhan$5,639
Campo$5,503
Canon City$3,595
Capulin$2,444
Carbondale$2,127
Carr$4,769
Cascade$5,511
Castle Pines$5,274
Castle Pines North$5,248
Castle Rock$5,249
Cedaredge$2,204
Centennial$5,156
Center$2,281
Central City$3,983
Chama$2,921
Cherry Creek$5,196
Cherry Hills Village$5,064
Cheyenne Wells$6,155
Chromo$2,302
Cimarron$2,389
Cimarron Hills$5,551
Clark$2,771
Clifton$1,959
Climax$2,670
Coal Creek$4,479
Coaldale$3,468
Coalmont$2,681
Collbran$2,437
Colorado City$4,774
Colorado Springs$5,427
Columbine$4,987
Columbine Valley$4,844
Commerce City$5,135
Como$3,641
Conejos$2,471
Conifer$5,239
Cope$5,869
Copper Mountain$2,502
Cortez$2,064
Cory$2,304
Cotopaxi$3,486
Cowdrey$2,988
Craig$2,355
Crawford$2,476
Creede$2,294
Crested Butte$2,191
Crestone$2,427
Cripple Creek$4,316
Crook$5,859
Crowley$5,712
Dacono$4,701
Dakota Ridge$5,037
De Beque$2,341
Deer Trail$5,978
Del Norte$2,303
Delta$2,045
Denver$5,187
Derby$5,119
Dillon$2,530
Dinosaur$2,712
Divide$4,453
Dolores$2,224
Dove Creek$2,164
Dove Valley$5,185
Drake$4,209
Dumont$3,416
Dupont$4,938
Durango$2,229
Eads$6,116
Eagle$2,278
East Pleasant View$4,981
Eastlake$4,762
Eaton$4,875
Eckert$2,088
Eckley$6,163
Edgewater$5,014
Edwards$2,173
Egnar$2,430
El Jebel$2,160
El Moro$4,452
Elbert$5,685
Eldorado Springs$4,932
Elizabeth$5,624
Empire$3,337
Englewood$5,035
Erie$4,578
Estes Park$3,572
Evans$4,881
Evergreen$4,625
Fairmount$4,943
Fairplay$3,116
Federal Heights$4,837
Firestone$4,466
Flagler$5,948
Fleming$5,974
Florence$3,692
Florissant$4,670
Fort Carson$5,197
Fort Collins$4,144
Fort Garland$3,027
Fort Lupton$4,894
Fort Lyon$5,708
Fort Morgan$5,923
Fountain$5,451
Fowler$5,110
Foxfield$5,392
Franktown$5,578
Fraser$2,759
Frederick$4,496
Frisco$2,489
Fruita$1,966
Fruitvale$1,933
Galeton$5,041
Garden City$4,992
Gardner$3,964
Gateway$2,147
Genesee$5,027
Genoa$5,551
Georgetown$3,329
Gilcrest$4,858
Gill$5,199
Glade Park$2,289
Glen Haven$3,997
Glendale$5,209
Gleneagle$5,361
Glenwood Springs$2,300
Golden$4,890
Granada$5,868
Granby$2,698
Grand Junction$1,954
Grand Lake$2,890
Grand View Estates$5,529
Granite$2,570
Grant$3,668
Greeley$4,924
Green Mountain Falls$5,534
Greenwood Village$5,155
Grover$5,101
Guffey$3,488
Gunbarrel$4,544
Gunnison$2,404
Gypsum$2,180
Hamilton$2,498
Hartman$5,642
Hartsel$3,252
Hasty$6,142
Haswell$5,902
Haxtun$6,068
Hayden$2,434
Henderson$5,007
Hereford$5,174
Hesperus$2,392
Highlands Ranch$5,081
Hillrose$5,833
Hillside$3,441
Hoehne$4,632
Holly$5,944
Holly Hills$5,078
Holyoke$6,356
Homelake$2,528
Hooper$2,449
Hot Sulphur Springs$2,716
Hotchkiss$2,180
Howard$3,384
Hudson$5,306
Hugo$5,818
Hygiene$4,265
Idaho Springs$3,619
Idalia$5,754
Idledale$5,162
Ignacio$2,210
Iliff$5,750
Indian Hills$4,967
Inverness$5,181
Jamestown$5,023
Jaroso$2,891
Jefferson$3,354
Joes$5,918
Johnstown$4,715
Julesburg$6,096
Karval$5,594
Keenesburg$5,428
Ken Caryl$4,979
Kersey$5,279
Keystone$2,539
Kim$4,790
Kiowa$5,554
Kirk$5,805
Kit Carson$5,922
Kittredge$4,797
Kremmling$2,486
La Jara$2,388
La Junta$5,638
La Salle$4,913
La Veta$4,008
Lafayette$4,695
Lake City$2,201
Lake George$3,932
Lakewood$5,000
Lamar$6,242
Laporte$4,179
Larkspur$5,257
Las Animas$5,766
Lazear$2,302
Leadville$2,447
Leadville North$2,444
Lewis$2,277
Limon$5,832
Lincoln Park$3,600
Lindon$5,806
Littleton$5,035
Livermore$4,199
Lochbuie$5,206
Log Lane Village$5,823
Loma$2,085
Lone Tree$5,332
Longmont$4,562
Louisville$4,739
Louviers$5,011
Loveland$4,153
Lucerne$5,015
Lyons$4,638
Mack$2,291
Manassa$2,437
Mancos$2,166
Manitou Springs$5,557
Manzanola$5,715
Marvel$2,324
Masonville$4,360
Matheson$5,914
Maybell$2,895
Mc Clave$5,600
Mc Coy$2,315
Mead$4,523
Meeker$2,499
Meredith$2,385
Meridian$5,422
Merino$5,981
Mesa$2,421
Mesa Verde National Park$2,311
Milliken$4,801
Minturn$2,348
Model$4,684
Moffat$2,550
Molina$2,245
Monarch$2,763
Monte Vista$2,368
Montrose$2,043
Monument$5,456
Morrison$5,135
Mosca$2,451
Mount Crested Butte$2,195
Mountain View$4,990
Mountain Village$2,137
Nathrop$2,401
Naturita$2,454
Nederland$4,788
New Castle$2,385
New Raymer$5,208
Niwot$4,493
North Washington$4,959
Northglenn$4,868
Norwood$2,523
Nucla$2,454
Nunn$4,974
Oak Creek$2,563
Ohio City$2,382
Olathe$2,078
Olney Springs$5,358
Ophir$2,341
Orchard$5,617
Orchard Mesa$1,961
Ordway$6,084
Otis$6,080
Ouray$2,158
Ovid$6,113
Padroni$5,781
Pagosa Springs$2,312
Palisade$2,034
Palmer Lake$5,586
Paoli$6,133
Paonia$2,204
Parachute$2,192
Paradox$2,237
Paragon Estates$4,542
Parker$5,517
Parlin$2,350
Parshall$2,708
Peetz$5,911
Penrose$3,849
Perry Park$5,326
Peyton$5,760
Phippsburg$2,518
Pierce$4,679
Pine$4,836
Pine Brook Hill$4,679
Pinecliffe$4,428
Pitkin$2,487
Placerville$2,552
Platteville$4,741
Pleasant View$2,278
Poncha Springs$2,642
Ponderosa Park$5,622
Powderhorn$2,302
Pritchett$5,495
Pueblo$5,374
Pueblo West$5,230
Ramah$5,477
Rand$2,649
Rangely$2,473
Red Cliff$2,446
Red Feather Lakes$4,010
Redlands$2,067
Redvale$2,328
Ridgway$2,230
Rifle$2,076
Rockvale$3,738
Rocky Ford$5,877
Roggen$5,176
Rollinsville$3,864
Romeo$2,524
Roxborough Park$5,148
Rush$5,794
Rye$4,887
Saguache$2,314
Salida$2,421
Salt Creek$5,447
San Luis$2,863
Sanford$2,408
Sargents$2,759
Security-Widefield$5,449
Sedalia$5,369
Sedgwick$6,010
Seibert$5,980
Severance$4,599
Shaw Heights$4,777
Shawnee$3,836
Sheridan$5,017
Sheridan Lake$5,870
Sherrelwood$5,031
Silt$2,125
Silver Plume$3,251
Silverthorne$2,499
Silverton$2,100
Simla$5,836
Slater$2,642
Snowmass$2,326
Snowmass Village$2,272
Snyder$5,957
Somerset$2,343
South Fork$2,308
Springfield$5,500
Steamboat Springs$2,426
Sterling$5,939
Stonegate$5,515
Stoneham$5,301
Strasburg$5,737
Stratmoor$5,496
Stratton$6,310
Sugar City$5,585
Sugarloaf$4,678
Superior$4,726
Swink$5,466
Tabernash$2,714
Telluride$2,118
The Pinery$5,573
Thornton$4,883
Timnath$4,026
Todd Creek$4,887
Toponas$2,486
Towaoc$2,123
Trinchera$4,601
Trinidad$4,353
Twin Lakes$4,673
Two Buttes$5,470
Upper Bear Creek$4,234
Usaf Academy$5,177
Vail$2,280
Vernon$5,947
Victor$4,285
Vilas$5,074
Villa Grove$2,475
Vona$5,741
Walden$2,691
Walsenburg$4,145
Walsh$5,688
Ward$4,722
Watkins$5,357
Welby$4,937
Weldona$5,809
Wellington$4,277
West Pleasant View$4,946
Westcliffe$3,702
Westminster$4,836
Weston$4,310
Wetmore$4,193
Wheat Ridge$4,965
Whitewater$2,103
Wiggins$5,863
Wild Horse$5,750
Wiley$6,015
Windsor$4,584
Winter Park$2,818
Wolcott$2,375
Woodland Park$4,403
Woodmoor$5,426
Woodrow$5,548
Woody Creek$2,456
Wray$5,982
Yampa$2,424
Yellow Jacket$2,234
Yoder$5,859
Yuma$6,351

Current state of homeowners insurance in Colorado

Homeowners insurance costs continue to rise across Colorado as insurers respond to more frequent hailstorms, wildfires and severe weather losses. 

LendingTree data shows the average cost of homeowners insurance in Colorado increased by around 89% between 2021 and 2025. Hail damage remains one of the biggest challenges for insurers across the state, especially along Colorado’s Front Range and eastern regions.

Wildfire risk and rebuilding expenses also continue to shape Colorado’s insurance market. The Colorado State Forest Service reports that about 2.5 million residents live in the wildland-urban interface, where more than 1 million people face a moderate to very high risk of wildfire exposure. 

LendingTree data also show the average Colorado home is 42 years old and spans about 2,464 square feet. Older homes may cost more to insure because aging systems can increase claim risk, while larger homes often require higher dwelling coverage limits and more expensive rebuild costs. 

Real-world scenario

Colorado homeowners continue to feel the impact of rising insurance rates tied to severe weather risks. In April 2026, Colorado Gov. Jared Polis proposed several measures aimed at reducing annual homeowners insurance costs by an average of $800 by the end of 2027.

How to compare homeowners insurance in Colorado

When comparing homeowners insurance companies in Colorado, look beyond the monthly premium alone. Coverage options, deductibles and policy exclusions can all affect how much financial protection you receive after a claim.

  • Coverage limits: Choose enough dwelling coverage to fully rebuild your home after a covered loss. Construction costs in Colorado can vary depending on location and home size. 
  • Deductibles: Higher deductibles usually lower your premium, but they also increase your out-of-pocket expenses after a claim, so make sure you know you can cover that cost. 
  • Exclusions: Standard homeowners insurance policies usually do not cover flood or earthquake damage. Colorado homeowners in wildfire- or hail-prone areas should also review coverage for roof and weather-related damage carefully. 
  • Add-ons: Optional coverages can help protect high-value belongings, home businesses or water backup damage that standard policies may not cover.

Bundling your home and auto insurance policies may also help lower your rates. Many insurance companies offer multipolicy discounts that can reduce premiums while keeping your coverage with one company. 

How LendingTree helps you find the right policy

Shopping for home insurance isn’t always straightforward — especially when availability and pricing can vary widely. LendingTree makes it easier by helping you explore options from multiple insurers so you can find coverage that fits your home, location and budget.

How it works

Tell us about your home

Answer a few quick questions about your home, location and coverage needs.

Compare options from insurers

See quotes and typical rates from insurers that offer coverage in your area.

Choose the right policy

Review your options and pick the coverage that fits your needs and budget.

Frequently asked questions

Colorado law does not require that you get homeowners insurance. However, most mortgage lenders will stipulate that you maintain home insurance until you pay off your loan. Getting home insurance is a good idea because it helps protect your finances should your home suffer damage from covered events like hail, fire or theft.

Colorado homeowners typically pay higher insurance premiums because insurers face elevated risks from hailstorms, wildfires and severe weather claims. Rising construction costs and higher rebuilding expenses have also contributed to recent rate increases across the state. 

Start shopping for new coverage as soon as you receive a nonrenewal notice. Comparing quotes from multiple insurers can help you find another policy before your current coverage ends. Homeowners in higher-risk wildfire areas may also benefit from completing mitigation improvements that could protect their homes from wildfire and make them more likely to be insured. 

Methodology

The rates shown in this article are based on an analysis of nonbinding quotes obtained in February 2026 from Quadrant Information Services for sample homes in every Colorado ZIP code. Unless otherwise noted, policies include:

  • Dwelling coverage: $400,000
  • Other structures: $40,000
  • Personal property: $200,000
  • Loss of use: $80,000
  • Personal liability: $100,000
  • Guest medical payments: $5,000
  • Deductible: $1,000

Our team of insurance experts rated insurance companies based on several categories. These categories include average rates, discounts, coverage options, third-party customer service ratings and app/website experience. We weighted these categories based on what customers value in an insurance company.

For third-party customer service ratings, we included the NAIC’s complaint index scores and financial strength ratings from AM Best. NAIC complaint index scores are used to determine how satisfied customers are with their claims, while financial strength ratings from AM Best reflect the ability to pay out claims.

See our home insurance ratings methodology and full editorial guidelines for further details.

*USAA is only available to current and former members of the military and eligible family members.