How to Compare Car Insurance Rates 2024
How Does LendingTree Get Paid?
LendingTree is compensated by companies on this site and this compensation may impact how and where offers appear on this site (such as the order). LendingTree does not include all lenders, savings products, or loan options available in the marketplace.

How Does LendingTree Get Paid?

LendingTree is compensated by companies on this site and this compensation may impact how and where offers appear on this site (such as the order). LendingTree does not include all lenders, savings products, or loan options available in the marketplace.

Cheap Car Insurance Quotes in Colorado (2025)

Updated on:
Content was accurate at the time of publication.

Best cheap car insurance in Colorado

$1,948/year
Cheapest full coverage: State Farm
State Farm logo
$3,892/year
Cheapest after DUI: Progressive
Progressive logo
$3,355/year
Cheapest for bad credit: Geico
Geico logo
+
More Options

Find the Cheapest Car Insurance Quotes in Colorado

State Farm has Colorado’s cheapest full-coverage car insurance quotes at $1,948 a year, or $162 a month. This is 33% less than the state average of $241 a month.

USAA has Colorado’s cheapest overall full-coverage rate. However, USAA is only available to the military community.

Cheapest car insurance companies in Colorado

Full-coverage car insurance rates by company

CompanyAnnual rateLendingTree score
state farm logoState Farm$1,9484.5 stars
auto-owners logoAuto-Owners$2,1695 stars
geico logoGeico$2,2713.5 stars
American Family logoAmerican Family$2,5284 stars
progressive logoProgressive$2,5694 stars
Allstate logoAllstate$3,5813 stars
nationwide logoNationwide$4,0273 stars
Farmers logoFarmers$5,0913 stars
usaa logoUSAA*$1,8404 stars

Auto-Owners is also a good company to contact for an auto insurance quote. Its rates are low, and it offers features like accident forgiveness and gap insurance, which you can’t get from State Farm.

Each company’s rates vary by customer. This is why it’s good to compare car insurance quotes from a few different companies when you shop or renew your policy.

At $57 a month, State Farm has the cheapest liability insurance quotes in Colorado. Progressive has the next-cheapest liability car insurance at $61 a month.

Of these two companies, State Farm has a higher overall customer satisfaction rating from J.D. Power.

Liability-only insurance rates

CompanyAnnual rate
State Farm$689
Progressive$727
Geico$784
American Family$786
Auto-Owners$806
Nationwide$1,329
Allstate$1,495
Farmers$1,665
USAA*$450

Find the Cheapest Car Insurance Quotes in Colorado

State Farm has Colorado’s cheapest car insurance for teens. The company charges young drivers an average of $198 a month for liability insurance.

Geico and American Family are next, charging $207 a month and $208 a month, respectively.

State Farm also has the cheapest full-coverage car insurance quotes for teen drivers at $467 a month.

Annual teen car insurance rates

CompanyLiability onlyFull coverage
State Farm$2,377$5,605
Geico$2,488$6,220
American Family$2,501$7,150
Auto-Owners$3,107$7,102
Progressive$3,497$10,935
Allstate$3,893$7,119
Nationwide$5,468$12,935
Farmers$6,345$16,973
USAA*$1,305$4,440

Young drivers usually get cheaper rates when added to a parent’s policy than they do on their own. A teen can usually also get discounts for:

  • Getting good grades in school
  • Completing an approved driver’s education or training program
  • Going off to college without a car
State Farm has Colorado’s cheapest car insurance for drivers with a bad record. State Farm’s rate of $174 a month after a speeding ticket is cheapest in the state. This is also 7% less than the next-cheapest rate of $188 a month from Auto-Owners.

A speeding ticket raises auto insurance rates by an average of 29% in Colorado. However, State Farm only raises its rates by 7% after a ticket.

Auto insurance rates after a ticket

CompanyAnnual rate
State Farm$2,086
Auto-Owners$2,262
American Family$2,972
Geico$3,036
Allstate$3,955
Progressive$4,135
Nationwide$5,806
Farmers$6,937
USAA*$2,291

At $186 a month, State Farm has Colorado’s cheapest auto insurance for drivers with an at-fault accident. State Farm’s rate is about half the state average of $376 a month.

State Farm’s rate is also 38% less than the next-cheapest rate of $301 a month from Auto-Owners.

Auto insurance rates after an accident

CompanyAnnual Rate
State Farm$2,237
Auto-Owners$3,615
American Family$3,748
Geico$4,300
Progressive$4,605
Allstate$5,483
Farmers$7,002
Nationwide$7,038
USAA*$2,592

An at-fault accident raises the average price of car insurance in Colorado by 56% to $376 a month. This is where accident forgiveness can help.

With accident forgiveness, your first at-fault accident won’t make your insurance rate go up. Some companies don’t offer it. Those that do usually make you pay a little extra to add it to your policy.

Auto-Owners and Progressive are among the companies that offer accident forgiveness. State Farm and Geico are among the companies that don’t.

State Farm also has the cheapest car insurance for teens with a bad driving record.

  • State Farm’s liability rates for teens with a speeding ticket average $218 a month. American Family’s rate is only slightly higher at $226 a month.
  • State Farm charges young drivers with an accident an average of $240 a month. This is 21% less than American Family’s rate of $306 a month.

Of the two companies, American Family has a slightly higher customer satisfaction rating from J.D. Power.

Annual insurance rates for teens with an incident

CompanyAfter ticketAfter accident
State Farm$2,617$2,879
American Family$2,710$3,667
Geico$2,929$4,001
Auto-Owners$3,262$5,529
Allstate$4,486$7,048
Progressive$4,689$4,974
Nationwide$5,940$6,011
Farmers$7,847$7,847
USAA*$1,467$1,525

Find the Cheapest Car Insurance Quotes in Colorado

Progressive has the cheapest DUI insurance rates in Colorado at $324 a month. Geico has the next-cheapest rate at $353 a month.

However, Geico offers a few more discounts than Progressive. These include discounts to military members, federal employees, and certain employee and membership groups. If you qualify, these discounts may make Geico a cheaper option for you.

Auto insurance rates after a DUI

CompanyAnnual rate
Progressive$3,892
Geico$4,233
American Family$4,416
Auto-Owners$4,486
State Farm$4,530
Allstate$4,724
Farmers$6,812
Nationwide$9,472
USAA*$3,809

Geico has the cheapest car insurance for Colorado drivers with bad credit at $280 a month. This is 22% less than the next-cheapest rate of $359 a month from American Family.

Insurers view your credit history as a sign of how risky you may be to insure. The average cost of bad credit car insurance in Colorado is $472 a month. This is nearly twice as much as drivers with good credit pay.

You can typically improve your credit by paying down debt and avoiding late payments. Once your credit score increases, shop for car insurance again. You are likely to get a cheaper rate.

Car insurance rates for drivers with bad credit

CompanyAnnual rate
Geico$3,355
American Family$4,303
Progressive$4,631
Allstate$6,032
Nationwide$6,131
Auto-Owners$6,577
State Farm$7,778
Farmers$8,404
USAA*$3,721

Auto-Owners and State Farm have the best ratings among Colorado car insurance companies. State Farm has cheaper rates, but Auto-Owners has a better complaint rating from the National Association of Insurance Commissioners (NAIC).

Auto-Owners is available from independent insurance agents. Most independent agents can get you quotes from a few companies at once, which is good for comparison shopping. Liberty Mutual and Nationwide also work with independent agents.

State Farm and Allstate are among the companies with exclusive agents. These agents can only quote their own company’s rates.

Colorado auto insurance company ratings

CompanyJ.D. PowerNAICLendingTree
Allstate6350.73 stars
American Family6600.44 stars
Auto-Owners6540.55 stars
Farmers6191.33 stars
Geico6370.73.5 stars
Nationwide6410.83 stars
Progressive6220.74 stars
State Farm6570.84.5 stars
USAA*7391.04 stars

*USAA only sells insurance to members of the military and their families.
**Source: J.D. Power 2024 U.S. Auto Insurance Study. Higher is better; 644 is average.

With rates at $268 a month, Glendale is Colorado’s most expensive city for auto insurance. Denver and Aurora tie for second-highest car insurance rates at $266 a month each. These rates are all at least 10% higher than the state average of $241 a month.

Fruita is the state’s cheapest city for car insurance at $174 a month. Its Mesa County neighbors Fruitvale and Grand Junction have the next-cheapest rates at $175 a month.

Drivers in Colorado Springs pay an average of $248 a month for car insurance. This is 3% higher than the state average. In Fort Collins, it costs an average of $204 a month, or 15% less than the state average.

Car insurance rates near you

Acres Green$2,857
Agate$3,002
Aguilar$2,799
Air Force Academy$2,868
Akron$2,976
Alamosa$2,549
Alamosa East$2,461
Allenspark$2,688
Alma$2,678
Almont$2,472
Amherst$2,851
Anton$2,871
Antonito$2,497
Applewood$2,807
Arapahoe$2,953
Arlington$2,906
Arriba$2,852
Arvada$2,751
Aspen$2,558
Atwood$2,773
Ault$2,531
Aurora$3,194
Austin$2,223
Avon$2,472
Avondale$2,967
Bailey$2,835
Basalt$2,515
Battlement Mesa$2,275
Bayfield$2,555
Bedrock$2,383
Bellvue$2,576
Bennett$2,892
Berkley$2,947
Berthoud$2,447
Bethune$2,917
Beulah$2,988
Black Forest$2,936
Black Hawk$2,766
Blanca$2,589
Blende$2,987
Blue River$2,545
Boncarbo$2,782
Bond$2,561
Boone$2,975
Boulder$2,617
Bow Mar$2,833
Branson$2,829
Breckenridge$2,550
Briggsdale$2,705
Brighton$2,789
Brookside$2,533
Broomfield$2,587
Brush$2,754
Buena Vista$2,505
Buffalo Creek$2,898
Burlington$2,874
Burns$2,552
Byers$2,891
Cahone$2,571
Calhan$2,948
Campo$2,844
Canon City$2,534
Capulin$2,515
Carbondale$2,443
Carr$2,585
Cascade$2,869
Castle Pines$2,850
Castle Pines North$2,838
Castle Rock$2,820
Cedaredge$2,264
Centennial$2,899
Center$2,466
Central City$2,722
Chama$2,610
Cherry Creek$2,902
Cherry Hills Village$2,997
Cheyenne Wells$2,952
Chromo$2,583
Cimarron$2,333
Cimarron Hills$3,017
Clark$2,491
Clifton$2,112
Climax$2,598
Coal Creek$2,770
Coaldale$2,598
Coalmont$2,591
Collbran$2,260
Colorado City$2,831
Colorado Springs$2,982
Columbine$2,809
Columbine Valley$2,807
Commerce City$2,994
Como$2,753
Conejos$2,536
Conifer$2,972
Cope$2,927
Copper Mountain$2,544
Cortez$2,474
Cory$2,236
Cotopaxi$2,625
Cowdrey$2,592
Craig$2,470
Crawford$2,340
Creede$2,571
Crested Butte$2,483
Crestone$2,560
Cripple Creek$2,757
Crook$2,712
Crowley$2,903
Dacono$2,650
Dakota Ridge$2,816
De Beque$2,184
Deer Trail$3,043
Del Norte$2,517
Delta$2,168
Denver$3,196
Derby$2,972
Dillon$2,535
Dinosaur$2,466
Divide$2,757
Dolores$2,495
Dove Creek$2,606
Dove Valley$2,853
Drake$2,525
Dumont$2,810
Dupont$3,005
Durango$2,457
Eads$2,886
Eagle$2,478
East Pleasant View$2,807
Eastlake$2,811
Eaton$2,550
Eckert$2,220
Eckley$2,916
Edgewater$3,101
Edwards$2,456
Egnar$2,539
El Jebel$2,460
El Moro$2,744
Elbert$2,932
Eldorado Springs$2,643
Elizabeth$2,883
Empire$2,769
Englewood$3,010
Erie$2,551
Estes Park$2,485
Evans$2,491
Evergreen$2,941
Fairmount$2,779
Fairplay$2,650
Federal Heights$2,969
Firestone$2,537
Flagler$2,967
Fleming$2,755
Florence$2,566
Florissant$2,725
Fort Carson$2,922
Fort Collins$2,444
Fort Garland$2,643
Fort Lupton$2,708
Fort Lyon$3,109
Fort Morgan$2,781
Fountain$2,953
Fowler$2,882
Foxfield$3,045
Franktown$2,888
Fraser$2,504
Frederick$2,595
Frisco$2,536
Fruita$2,082
Fruitvale$2,100
Galeton$2,536
Garden City$2,548
Gardner$2,890
Gateway$2,177
Genesee$2,865
Genoa$2,892
Georgetown$2,759
Gilcrest$2,579
Gill$2,577
Glade Park$2,149
Glen Haven$2,473
Glendale$3,214
Gleneagle$2,834
Glenwood Springs$2,331
Golden$2,813
Granada$2,905
Granby$2,493
Grand Junction$2,100
Grand Lake$2,512
Grand View Estates$2,787
Granite$2,550
Grant$2,656
Greeley$2,507
Green Mountain Falls$2,893
Greenwood Village$2,865
Grover$2,664
Guffey$2,681
Gunbarrel$2,545
Gunnison$2,513
Gypsum$2,452
Hamilton$2,478
Hartman$2,897
Hartsel$2,669
Hasty$2,879
Haswell$2,893
Haxtun$2,828
Hayden$2,425
Henderson$2,909
Hereford$2,622
Hesperus$2,554
Highlands Ranch$2,820
Hillrose$2,748
Hillside$2,657
Hoehne$2,778
Holly$2,934
Holly Hills$3,147
Holyoke$2,887
Homelake$2,531
Hooper$2,502
Hot Sulphur Springs$2,488
Hotchkiss$2,325
Howard$2,570
Hudson$2,732
Hugo$2,927
Hygiene$2,595
Idaho Springs$2,831
Idalia$2,918
Idledale$2,925
Ignacio$2,533
Iliff$2,722
Indian Hills$2,960
Inverness$2,856
Jamestown$2,803
Jaroso$2,586
Jefferson$2,727
Joes$2,904
Johnstown$2,513
Julesburg$2,918
Karval$2,846
Keenesburg$2,701
Ken Caryl$2,786
Kersey$2,582
Keystone$2,534
Kim$2,792
Kiowa$3,021
Kirk$2,890
Kit Carson$2,959
Kittredge$2,959
Kremmling$2,543
La Jara$2,432
La Junta$2,844
La Salle$2,582
La Veta$2,847
Lafayette$2,517
Lake City$2,613
Lake George$2,765
Lakewood$2,970
Lamar$2,817
Laporte$2,405
Larkspur$2,948
Las Animas$2,928
Lazear$2,319
Leadville$2,607
Leadville North$2,606
Lewis$2,456
Limon$2,941
Lincoln Park$2,534
Lindon$2,891
Littleton$2,799
Livermore$2,590
Lochbuie$2,759
Log Lane Village$2,806
Loma$2,104
Lone Tree$2,876
Longmont$2,508
Louisville$2,522
Louviers$2,804
Loveland$2,420
Lucerne$2,517
Lyons$2,664
Mack$2,120
Manassa$2,448
Mancos$2,468
Manitou Springs$2,937
Manzanola$2,882
Marvel$2,590
Masonville$2,430
Matheson$3,068
Maybell$2,476
Mc Clave$2,903
Mc Coy$2,538
Mead$2,531
Meeker$2,435
Meredith$2,541
Meridian$2,798
Merino$2,787
Mesa$2,245
Mesa Verde National Park$2,485
Milliken$2,504
Minturn$2,506
Model$2,785
Moffat$2,564
Molina$2,262
Monarch$2,452
Monte Vista$2,470
Montrose$2,206
Monument$2,890
Morrison$2,931
Mosca$2,532
Mount Crested Butte$2,485
Mountain View$3,039
Mountain Village$2,591
Nathrop$2,480
Naturita$2,432
Nederland$2,808
New Castle$2,356
New Raymer$2,680
Niwot$2,520
North Washington$2,938
Northglenn$2,843
Norwood$2,605
Nucla$2,435
Nunn$2,582
Oak Creek$2,528
Ohio City$2,485
Olathe$2,183
Olney Springs$2,953
Ophir$2,571
Orchard$2,741
Orchard Mesa$2,104
Ordway$2,981
Otis$2,914
Ouray$2,591
Ovid$2,947
Padroni$2,745
Pagosa Springs$2,546
Palisade$2,140
Palmer Lake$2,854
Paoli$2,840
Paonia$2,326
Parachute$2,277
Paradox$2,420
Paragon Estates$2,582
Parker$2,796
Parlin$2,447
Parshall$2,541
Peetz$2,743
Penrose$2,616
Perry Park$2,922
Peyton$2,920
Phippsburg$2,518
Pierce$2,530
Pine$2,991
Pine Brook Hill$2,666
Pinecliffe$2,744
Pitkin$2,453
Placerville$2,558
Platteville$2,639
Pleasant View$2,462
Poncha Springs$2,459
Ponderosa Park$2,902
Powderhorn$2,480
Pritchett$2,872
Pueblo$2,976
Pueblo West$2,838
Ramah$3,002
Rand$2,564
Rangely$2,427
Red Cliff$2,519
Red Feather Lakes$2,587
Redlands$2,101
Redvale$2,467
Ridgway$2,567
Rifle$2,276
Rockvale$2,599
Rocky Ford$2,913
Roggen$2,719
Rollinsville$2,720
Romeo$2,524
Roxborough Park$2,820
Rush$3,041
Rye$2,866
Saguache$2,497
Salida$2,444
Salt Creek$3,015
San Luis$2,657
Sanford$2,461
Sargents$2,534
Security-Widefield$2,882
Sedalia$2,904
Sedgwick$2,939
Seibert$3,007
Severance$2,518
Shaw Heights$2,825
Shawnee$2,795
Sheridan$3,100
Sheridan Lake$2,898
Sherrelwood$3,009
Silt$2,310
Silver Plume$2,804
Silverthorne$2,559
Silverton$2,632
Simla$2,998
Slater$2,480
Snowmass$2,560
Snowmass Village$2,576
Snyder$2,719
Somerset$2,450
South Fork$2,562
Springfield$2,852
Steamboat Springs$2,462
Sterling$2,718
Stonegate$2,788
Stoneham$2,736
Strasburg$2,888
Stratmoor$2,941
Stratton$2,926
Sugar City$2,931
Sugarloaf$2,749
Superior$2,510
Swink$2,919
Tabernash$2,505
Telluride$2,592
The Pinery$2,819
Thornton$2,905
Timnath$2,535
Todd Creek$2,760
Toponas$2,522
Towaoc$2,477
Trinchera$2,752
Trinidad$2,749
Twin Lakes$2,942
Two Buttes$2,832
Upper Bear Creek$2,877
Usaf Academy$2,871
Vail$2,508
Vernon$2,903
Victor$2,782
Vilas$2,791
Villa Grove$2,494
Vona$2,913
Walden$2,514
Walsenburg$2,902
Walsh$2,856
Ward$2,761
Watkins$2,936
Welby$2,940
Weldona$2,765
Wellington$2,401
West Pleasant View$2,821
Westcliffe$2,755
Westminster$2,787
Weston$2,804
Wetmore$2,772
Wheat Ridge$2,925
Whitewater$2,166
Wiggins$2,773
Wild Horse$2,957
Wiley$2,849
Windsor$2,524
Winter Park$2,524
Wolcott$2,477
Woodland Park$2,829
Woodmoor$2,886
Woodrow$2,951
Woody Creek$2,529
Wray$2,885
Yampa$2,530
Yellow Jacket$2,508
Yoder$3,026
Yuma$2,894

Colorado law requires you to have car insurance at all times. You have to show proof of insurance to register your car and renew its registration each year.

The state also uses an online system to verify your insurance status. Insurance companies report new policies, cancellations and lapses to the DMV. The system sends you a letter if it detects a lapse in your coverage.

If this happens to you, you need to get your insurance documents in order to avoid legal penalties.

The penalties for driving without insurance in Colorado include a fine and possible driver’s license suspension. You may also have to perform 40 hours of community service.

Minimum coverage for car insurance in Colorado

At a minimum, you need a car insurance policy with at least the following liability coverage limits in Colorado:

  • Bodily injury liability: $25,000 per person, $50,000 per accident
  • Property damage liability: $15,000

Liability covers injuries and damage you cause to other people or their property. If an accident victim’s medical or car repair costs exceed your liability limits, the shortfall comes out of your pocket. Getting higher liability limits can protect you from potential out-of-pocket costs like these.

Your insurance agent must offer uninsured motorist and medical payments coverage. Both are good to have, but you don’t have to buy them.

Collision and comprehensive (comp) are not required by law. However, you typically need both for a car loan or to lease a vehicle.

SR-22 insurance in Colorado

You usually need SR-22 car insurance to reinstate your driving privileges after a major violation like DUI (driving under the influence). An SR-22 is a form that certifies you have insurance.

Your insurance agent gives you the form when you purchase your policy. You have to send your certificate to the DMV. You can submit it online or by snail mail. If you switch car insurance companies, make sure to get your new SR-22 certificate to the DMV as soon as possible.

Let your insurance company, or the ones you contact for quotes, know about your SR-22 requirement up front. Some companies don’t offer SR-22s. Those that do may add a small filing fee to your rate.

The actual price you pay for SR-22 insurance depends on your driving record. You’ll pay more for SR-22 insurance after a DUI than you will after a less-severe violation.

The average cost of car insurance in Colorado is $241 a month for full coverage. You’ll pay more if you have a prior incident on your record or bad credit. A speeding ticket raises the average cost of car insurance by 29%. Rates go up by 56% after an accident.

Yes, you can get SR-22 insurance in Colorado if you don’t have a car. Several companies offer non-owner car insurance. A non-owner’s policy allows you to legally drive cars you borrow or rent while your SR-22 requirement is in place.

State Farm has the cheapest car insurance for most Colorado drivers. It charges a typical adult driver $162 a month for full coverage. Geico is the cheapest company for drivers with bad credit, while Progressive is cheapest after a DUI.

Methodology

LendingTree uses insurance rate data from Quadrant Information Services using publicly sourced insurance company filings. Rates are based on an analysis of hundreds of thousands of car insurance quotes for a typical driver. Prices are shown for comparative purposes only. Your own rates may be different.

Unless noted otherwise, quotes are for a full-coverage policy for a 30-year-old man with good credit and a clean driving record who drives a 2015 Honda Civic EX.

Minimum-liability policies provide liability coverage with the state’s required minimum limits.

Full-coverage policies include collision, comprehensive and liability coverage:

  • Bodily injury liability: $50,000 per person, $100,000 per accident
  • Property damage liability: $25,000
  • Uninsured / underinsured motorist bodily injury: $50,000 per person and $100,000 per accident
  • Medical payments: $5,000
  • Collision: $500 deductible
  • Comprehensive: $500 deductible


Our team of insurance experts rated insurance companies based on several categories. These categories include average rates, discounts, coverage options, third-party customer service ratings and app/website experience. We weighted these categories based on what customers value in an insurance company.

For third-party customer service ratings, we included NAIC’s Complaint Index scores and financial strength ratings from AM Best. NAIC Complaint Index scores are used to determine how satisfied customers are with their claims, while financial strength ratings from AM Best reflect the ability to pay out claims.

*USAA is only available to current and former members of the military as well as certain family members.