How to Compare Car Insurance Rates 2024
How Does LendingTree Get Paid?
LendingTree is compensated by companies on this site and this compensation may impact how and where offers appear on this site (such as the order). LendingTree does not include all lenders, savings products, or loan options available in the marketplace.

How Does LendingTree Get Paid?

LendingTree is compensated by companies on this site and this compensation may impact how and where offers appear on this site (such as the order). LendingTree does not include all lenders, savings products, or loan options available in the marketplace.

Cheapest Car Insurance in Maine (2025)

Updated on:
Content was accurate at the time of publication.

Best cheap car insurance in Maine

$938/year
Cheapest full coverage: Travelers
Travelers logo
$1,161/year
Cheap after an accident: State Farm
State Farm logo
$1,429/year
Best for teens with ticket: Concord
Concord Group logo
+
More Options

Find the Cheapest Car Insurance Quotes in Maine

At $938 a year, or $78 a month, Travelers has the cheapest full-coverage car insurance for most Maine drivers. MMG is the second-cheapest company for full-coverage policies at $91 a month.

Along with low full-coverage Full-coverage car insurance combines collision, comprehensive and liability auto insurance. Full coverage takes care of your own injuries and property damage after an accident. rates, Travelers offers gap insurance. Gap insurance is great if you have a new, financed vehicle, as it can protect you if your car is totaled.

Cheapest car insurance companies in Maine

Cheapest companies for full coverage

CompanyAnnual rateLendingTree score
travelers logoTravelers$9384.5 stars
MMGMMG$1,0964 stars
concord group logoConcord$1,1094 stars
state farm logoState Farm$1,1614.5 stars
geico logoGeico$1,2633.5 stars
progressive logoProgressive$1,2964 stars
allstate logoAllstate$1,7113 stars
farmers logoFarmers$1,8513 stars
usaa logoUSAA*$7604 stars

While USAA has the overall cheapest full-coverage rate in Maine, it only sells car insurance for military members and their families.

MMG offers the cheapest liability car insurance in Maine at $407 a year, or $34 a month. Travelers is next at $38 a month, though it offers several discounts that could make it the cheapest for you.

Maine requires drivers to carry at least a minimum amount of liability car insurance, which covers the medical and repair bills of others if you cause an accident.

Cheapest companies for minimum coverage

CompanyAnnual rate
MMG$407
Travelers$453
State Farm$488
Geico$538
Concord$547
Farmers$583
Progressive$771
Allstate$812
USAA*$285

Find the Cheapest Car Insurance Quotes in Maine

Teen drivers in Maine get the cheapest liability car insurance with Travelers at $1,179 a year. Concord has Maine’s cheapest full-coverage insurance for teens at $2,276 a year.

Parents looking for cheap car insurance for teens should add them to their current policy. While your rates will go up, it should still be cheaper than if you had separate car insurance policies.

Cheapest companies for teens

CompanyLiability onlyFull coverage
Travelers$1,179$2,514
Concord$1,241$2,276
MMG$1,471$3,545
State Farm$1,605$3,561
Geico$1,910$4,266
Allstate$2,004$4,637
Farmers$2,124$6,737
Progressive$3,454$6,840
USAA*$751$1,930

Maine drivers looking for cheap car insurance with a speeding ticket can get it from Travelers, which charges $1,235 a year, or $103 a month. State Farm is the second-cheapest company at $104 a month.

Both State Farm and Travelers offer a wide range of discounts that could lower your rate and make it your cheapest option.

A speeding ticket or similar violation stays on your record for one year in Maine. You should expect to pay around 28% more for car insurance during this time.

Cheapest companies after a ticket

CompanyAnnual rate
Travelers$1,235
State Farm$1,251
Concord$1,277
Geico$1,329
MMG$1,444
Progressive$1,737
Allstate$1,911
Farmers$3,223
USAA*$858

State Farm has the cheapest full-coverage car insurance after an accident in Maine at $1,161 a year, or $97 a month. MMG is next at around $112 a month.

Car insurance rates go up by around 56% after an at-fault accident in Maine.

Cheapest companies after an accident

CompanyAnnual rate
State Farm$1,161
MMG$1,346
Travelers$1,384
Concord$1,745
Progressive$2,116
Geico$2,281
Allstate$2,460
Farmers$3,759
USAA*$1,142

Cheap insurance in Maine for bad teen drivers: Concord and State Farm

Teens in Maine with a ticket on their record get the cheapest car insurance from Concord at $1,429 a year. State Farm has the cheapest rate for teens after an accident at $1,605 a year.

Cheapest companies for teens with bad records

CompanyTicketAccident
Concord$1,429$1,984
Travelers$1,507$1,774
State Farm$1,753$1,605
MMG$1,852$1,903
Geico$2,118$2,887
Allstate$2,271$3,124
Farmers$2,912$3,565
Progressive$3,726$3,972
USAA*$1,115$1,613

Find the Cheapest Car Insurance Quotes in Maine

Travelers offers the best cheap car insurance with an OUI in Maine at $1,423 a year, or $119 a month. Progressive is the next-cheapest option at $128 a month.

An operating under the influence (OUI) conviction usually leads to fines, jail time and license suspension. You can also expect your car insurance rates to jump about 91% after a DUI in Maine.

Cheapest companies after a OUI

CompanyAnnual rate
Travelers$1,423
Progressive$1,534
MMG$1,840
Concord$1,865
Allstate$2,348
State Farm$2,847
Geico$3,824
Farmers$4,100
USAA*$1,527

At $1,530 a year, or $128 a month, Travelers has the cheapest car insurance rate for Maine drivers with poor credit. MMG has the second-cheapest rate of $146 a month.

Car insurance companies may charge higher rates to drivers with poor credit because they see a link between credit score and the risk of filing a claim.

Cheapest companies for drivers with poor credit

CompanyAnnual rate
Travelers$1,530
MMG$1,754
Geico$1,904
Concord$1,928
Progressive$2,268
Allstate$2,580
State Farm$4,891
Farmers$5,716
USAA*$1,246

To learn your credit score, you can find out for free at LendingTree Spring before you shop for insurance.

Travelers and State Farm are the best car insurance companies in Maine, mostly because of their low rates. Both also offer more discounts than most companies, which can make your payment even cheaper.

State Farm has a much better customer satisfaction rating than Travelers. In fact, State Farm earned the highest J.D. Power score of the companies we surveyed in Maine. However, Travelers offers gap insurance while State Farm does not.

Maine car insurance company ratings

CompanyJ.D. Power**AM BestLendingTree
Allstate635A+3 stars
ConcordNot ratedA+4 stars
Farmers619A3 stars
Geico637A++3.5 stars
MMGNot ratedA4 stars
Progressive622A+4 stars
State Farm657A++4.5 stars
Travelers616A++4.5 stars
USAA*739A++4 stars

*USAA only sells insurance to members of the military and their families.
**Source: J.D. Power 2024 U.S. Auto Insurance Study. Higher is better; 644 is average.

USAA is rated but not ranked in the J.D. Power 2024 U.S. Auto Insurance Study due to its limited policyholder base.

Chebeague Island and Presque Isle share the cheapest average car insurance rate in Maine at $1,178 a year. Center Lovell has the state’s highest average car insurance rate at $1,377 a year.

Car insurance rates near you

CityAnnual rate% from average
Abbot$1,240-3%
Acton$1,3395%
Addison$1,3112%
Albion$1,3032%
Alfred$1,2780%
Alna$1,3143%
Andover$1,2991%
Anson$1,3193%
Ashland$1,198-6%
Athens$1,3183%
Auburn$1,3243%
Augusta$1,2881%
Aurora$1,3022%
Bailey Island$1,221-5%
Bangor$1,259-2%
Bar Harbor$1,2871%
Bar Mills$1,3042%
Bass Harbor$1,2951%
Bath$1,241-3%
Beals$1,3032%
Belfast$1,266-1%
Belgrade$1,3435%
Belgrade Lakes$1,3415%
Benedicta$1,214-5%
Bernard$1,3042%
Berwick$1,2921%
Bethel$1,2911%
Biddeford$1,232-4%
Biddeford Pool$1,260-2%
Bingham$1,2790%
Birch Harbor$1,3092%
Blaine$1,205-6%
Blue Hill$1,3475%
Boothbay$1,2951%
Boothbay Harbor$1,3022%
Bowdoin$1,259-2%
Bowdoinham$1,246-3%
Bradford$1,258-2%
Bradley$1,237-3%
Bremen$1,3364%
Brewer$1,265-1%
Bridgewater$1,179-8%
Bridgton$1,3253%
Bristol$1,3294%
Brooklin$1,3274%
Brooks$1,2760%
Brooksville$1,3284%
Brookton$1,2961%
Brownfield$1,3354%
Brownville$1,223-5%
Brownville Junction$1,2750%
Brunswick$1,196-7%
Brunswick Station$1,193-7%
Bryant Pond$1,3042%
Buckfield$1,3314%
Bucksport$1,3243%
Burlington$1,231-4%
Burnham$1,2750%
Bustins Island$1,222-5%
Buxton$1,270-1%
Calais$1,2830%
Cambridge$1,2780%
Camden$1,242-3%
Canaan$1,2850%
Canton$1,3304%
Cape Elizabeth$1,210-6%
Cape Neddick$1,256-2%
Cape Porpoise$1,2810%
Caratunk$1,2820%
Caribou$1,203-6%
Carmel$1,2790%
Casco$1,3122%
Castine$1,3294%
Center Lovell$1,3778%
Chamberlain$1,3173%
Charleston$1,260-2%
Chebeague Island$1,178-8%
Cherryfield$1,3253%
China Village$1,3223%
Chisholm$1,3082%
Clayton Lake$1,200-6%
Cliff Island$1,218-5%
Clinton$1,2921%
Columbia Falls$1,3133%
Coopers Mills$1,3284%
Corea$1,3173%
Corinna$1,261-2%
Corinth$1,2860%
Cornish$1,3193%
Cousins Island$1,189-7%
Cranberry Isles$1,3002%
Crouseville$1,232-4%
Cumberland Center$1,202-6%
Cumberland Foreside$1,203-6%
Cushing$1,2770%
Cutler$1,3334%
Damariscotta$1,3405%
Danforth$1,2870%
Danville$1,3002%
Deer Isle$1,3173%
Denmark$1,3495%
Dennysville$1,3284%
Detroit$1,2881%
Dexter$1,253-2%
Dixfield$1,3183%
Dixmont$1,3012%
Dover-Foxcroft$1,241-3%
Dresden$1,3102%
Dryden$1,3112%
Durham$1,2810%
Eagle Lake$1,229-4%
East Andover$1,3072%
East Baldwin$1,3294%
East Blue Hill$1,3334%
East Boothbay$1,2981%
East Dixfield$1,3274%
East Livermore$1,3243%
East Machias$1,3284%
East Millinocket$1,194-7%
East Newport$1,3133%
East Orland$1,2850%
East Parsonsfield$1,3526%
East Poland$1,3576%
East Vassalboro$1,3243%
East Waterboro$1,2941%
East Wilton$1,3274%
East Winthrop$1,3384%
Easton$1,181-8%
Eastport$1,3062%
Eddington$1,266-1%
Edgecomb$1,3042%
Eliot$1,261-2%
Ellsworth$1,3122%
Estcourt Station$1,257-2%
Etna$1,274-1%
Eustis$1,2871%
Exeter$1,2840%
Fairfield$1,270-1%
Falmouth$1,220-5%
Falmouth Foreside$1,207-6%
Farmingdale$1,2760%
Farmington$1,3001%
Farmington Falls$1,3001%
Fort Fairfield$1,196-7%
Fort Kent$1,208-6%
Fort Kent Mills$1,243-3%
Frankfort$1,2961%
Franklin$1,3314%
Freedom$1,3143%
Freeport$1,229-4%
Frenchboro$1,2760%
Frenchville$1,215-5%
Friendship$1,2911%
Fryeburg$1,3364%
Gardiner$1,2931%
Garland$1,259-2%
Georgetown$1,240-3%
Gorham$1,237-3%
Gouldsboro$1,3173%
Grand Isle$1,217-5%
Grand Lake Stream$1,3243%
Gray$1,230-4%
Greenbush$1,248-3%
Greene$1,3505%
Greenville$1,224-4%
Greenville Junction$1,235-4%
Greenwood$1,3122%
Guilford$1,244-3%
Hallowell$1,2860%
Hampden$1,267-1%
Hancock$1,3213%
Hanover$1,3062%
Harborside$1,3112%
Harmony$1,2871%
Harpswell$1,203-6%
Harrington$1,3112%
Harrison$1,2971%
Hartland$1,2941%
Hebron$1,3233%
Hinckley$1,3183%
Hiram$1,3536%
Holden$1,2760%
Hollis Center$1,2780%
Hope$1,242-3%
Houlton$1,199-6%
Howland$1,204-6%
Hudson$1,2780%
Hulls Cove$1,3264%
Island Falls$1,214-5%
Isle Au Haut$1,262-1%
Isle of Springs$1,3223%
Islesboro$1,254-2%
Islesford$1,3012%
Jackman$1,244-3%
Jay$1,3062%
Jefferson$1,3364%
Jonesboro$1,3193%
Jonesport$1,3133%
Kenduskeag$1,267-1%
Kennebunk$1,223-5%
Kennebunkport$1,251-2%
Kents Hill$1,3143%
Kingfield$1,2931%
Kingman$1,243-3%
Kittery$1,254-2%
Kittery Point$1,255-2%
Lagrange$1,241-3%
Lake Arrowhead$1,2941%
Lambert Lake$1,3223%
Lebanon$1,3062%
Lee$1,214-5%
Leeds$1,3243%
Levant$1,271-1%
Lewiston$1,3415%
Liberty$1,2941%
Limerick$1,3203%
Limestone$1,207-6%
Limington$1,2971%
Lincoln$1,188-7%
Lincolnville$1,256-2%
Lincolnville Center$1,2911%
Lisbon$1,2921%
Lisbon Falls$1,2840%
Litchfield$1,3354%
Little Deer Isle$1,3092%
Little Falls$1,235-4%
Livermore$1,3253%
Livermore Falls$1,3274%
Long Island$1,213-5%
Lovell$1,3253%
Lubec$1,3294%
Machias$1,3193%
Machiasport$1,3274%
Madawaska$1,214-5%
Madison$1,3032%
Manchester$1,3122%
Mapleton$1,202-6%
Mars Hill$1,183-8%
Matinicus$1,2951%
Mattawamkeag$1,202-6%
Mechanic Falls$1,3052%
Meddybemps$1,3153%
Medway$1,193-7%
Mexico$1,2860%
Milbridge$1,3133%
Milford$1,238-3%
Millinocket$1,195-7%
Milo$1,251-2%
Minot$1,3425%
Monhegan$1,3364%
Monmouth$1,3364%
Monroe$1,2921%
Monson$1,232-4%
Monticello$1,191-7%
Moody$1,269-1%
Morrill$1,267-1%
Mount Desert$1,2991%
Mount Vernon$1,3344%
Naples$1,3163%
New Gloucester$1,2951%
New Harbor$1,3052%
New Limerick$1,234-4%
New Portland$1,3072%
New Sharon$1,2941%
New Sweden$1,202-6%
New Vineyard$1,3102%
Newcastle$1,3334%
Newport$1,267-1%
Newry$1,2790%
Nobleboro$1,3495%
Norridgewock$1,2981%
North Anson$1,3032%
North Berwick$1,264-1%
North Bridgton$1,3052%
North Haven$1,229-4%
North Jay$1,3284%
North Monmouth$1,3143%
North Turner$1,3677%
North Vassalboro$1,3173%
North Waterboro$1,2850%
North Waterford$1,3143%
North Windham$1,255-2%
North Yarmouth$1,220-5%
Northeast Harbor$1,2921%
Norway$1,2911%
Oakfield$1,204-6%
Oakland$1,2941%
Ocean Park$1,264-1%
Ogunquit$1,241-3%
Old Orchard Beach$1,233-4%
Old Town$1,244-3%
Oquossoc$1,2961%
Orient$1,216-5%
Orland$1,3314%
Orono$1,268-1%
Orrington$1,240-3%
Orrs Island$1,204-6%
Owls Head$1,249-3%
Oxbow$1,211-5%
Oxford$1,3102%
Palermo$1,274-1%
Palmyra$1,2961%
Parsonsfield$1,3374%
Passadumkeag$1,253-2%
Patten$1,190-7%
Peaks Island$1,227-4%
Pemaquid$1,3143%
Pembroke$1,3022%
Penobscot$1,3324%
Perham$1,206-6%
Perry$1,3274%
Peru$1,3153%
Phillips$1,3052%
Phippsburg$1,247-3%
Pittsfield$1,274-1%
Plymouth$1,266-1%
Poland$1,3223%
Port Clyde$1,2790%
Portage$1,194-7%
Porter$1,3465%
Portland$1,264-1%
Pownal$1,263-1%
Presque Isle$1,178-8%
Princeton$1,2850%
Prospect Harbor$1,3132%
Randolph$1,2840%
Rangeley$1,2770%
Raymond$1,2800%
Readfield$1,3183%
Richmond$1,240-3%
Robbinston$1,2991%
Rockland$1,228-4%
Rockport$1,228-4%
Rockwood$1,257-2%
Round Pond$1,3183%
Roxbury$1,3102%
Rumford$1,2911%
Sabattus$1,2971%
Saco$1,237-3%
Salsbury Cove$1,2860%
Sandy Point$1,3213%
Sanford$1,2860%
Sangerville$1,249-2%
Sargentville$1,3163%
Scarborough$1,211-5%
Seal Cove$1,3012%
Seal Harbor$1,2991%
Searsmont$1,2961%
Searsport$1,2790%
Sebago$1,3153%
Sebasco Estates$1,2870%
Sebec$1,233-4%
Sedgwick$1,3344%
Shapleigh$1,3264%
Shawmut$1,3203%
Sheridan$1,234-4%
Sherman$1,217-5%
Shirley Mills$1,2790%
Sinclair$1,222-5%
Skowhegan$1,3032%
Smithfield$1,3112%
Smyrna Mills$1,200-6%
Solon$1,3052%
Sorrento$1,3193%
South Berwick$1,274-1%
South Bristol$1,3112%
South Casco$1,2881%
South China$1,3032%
South Eliot$1,261-2%
South Freeport$1,2931%
South Gardiner$1,3314%
South Paris$1,3213%
South Portland$1,227-4%
South Sanford$1,2770%
South Thomaston$1,269-1%
South Windham$1,258-2%
Southport$1,3012%
Southwest Harbor$1,2991%
Springfield$1,219-5%
Springvale$1,2780%
Spruce Head$1,269-1%
Squirrel Island$1,3334%
St. Agatha$1,220-5%
St. Albans$1,2991%
St. David$1,215-5%
St. Francis$1,220-5%
Stacyville$1,217-5%
Standish$1,255-2%
Steep Falls$1,2790%
Stetson$1,269-1%
Steuben$1,3284%
Stillwater$1,2931%
Stockholm$1,211-5%
Stockton Springs$1,2931%
Stoneham$1,3304%
Stonington$1,2951%
Stratton$1,273-1%
Strong$1,3223%
Sullivan$1,3052%
Sumner$1,3445%
Sunset$1,2810%
Surry$1,3294%
Swans Island$1,2871%
Temple$1,2951%
Tenants Harbor$1,252-2%
Thomaston$1,240-3%
Thorndike$1,3082%
Topsfield$1,2881%
Topsham$1,222-5%
Trevett$1,3243%
Troy$1,2901%
Turner$1,3405%
Union$1,272-1%
Unity$1,2971%
Van Buren$1,229-4%
Vanceboro$1,3384%
Vassalboro$1,3112%
Vienna$1,3253%
Vinalhaven$1,232-4%
Waite$1,2981%
Waldoboro$1,3576%
Wallagrass$1,219-5%
Walpole$1,2891%
Warren$1,2911%
Washburn$1,195-7%
Washington$1,2981%
Waterboro$1,2941%
Waterford$1,2931%
Waterville$1,2971%
Wayne$1,3183%
Weld$1,2881%
Wells$1,222-5%
Wesley$1,3233%
West Baldwin$1,3445%
West Bethel$1,3475%
West Boothbay Harbor$1,3304%
West Enfield$1,211-5%
West Farmington$1,3203%
West Forks$1,269-1%
West Kennebunk$1,228-4%
West Minot$1,3717%
West Newfield$1,3475%
West Paris$1,3344%
West Poland$1,3767%
West Rockport$1,2951%
Westbrook$1,232-4%
Westfield$1,199-6%
Whitefield$1,2871%
Whiting$1,3233%
Wilton$1,3022%
Windham$1,256-2%
Windsor$1,2901%
Winn$1,226-4%
Winslow$1,2870%
Winter Harbor$1,3022%
Winterport$1,2820%
Winthrop$1,3102%
Wiscasset$1,3062%
Woodland Washington County$1,2941%
Woolwich$1,267-1%
Wytopitlock$1,215-5%
Yarmouth$1,191-7%
York$1,252-2%
York Beach$1,2951%
York Harbor$1,250-2%

Maine drivers are required to have at least a minimum amount of car insurance. You need medical payments, liability and uninsured/underinsured motorist coverage in Maine.

Maine car insurance requirements

Coverage typeMinimum amount needed
Liability (bodily injury)$50,000 per person
$100,000 per accident
Liability (property damage)$25,000 per accident
Uninsured/underinsured motorist$50,000 per person
$100,000 per accident
Medical payments$2,000

State law doesn’t require full-coverage car insurance in Maine. But if you financed your vehicle, your lender will probably require full coverage as part of the lending agreement.

SR-22 insurance in Maine

If your driver’s license is suspended in Maine, you are required to file an SR-22 to get it reinstated.

An SR-22 proves you carry the minimum amount of car insurance the state requires. Your insurance company should file the SR-22 with the Bureau of Motor Vehicles (BMV) for you.

The average cost of full-coverage car insurance in Maine is $1,243 a year, or $104 a month. Liability-only car insurance costs $543 a year, or $45 a month, on average.

Maine is an at-fault car insurance state. This means the person responsible for the accident pays for resulting injuries and damage.

Methodology

LendingTree uses insurance rate data from Quadrant Information Services using publicly sourced insurance company filings. Rates are based on an analysis of hundreds of thousands of car insurance quotes for a typical driver. Prices are shown for comparative purposes only. Your own rates may be different.

Unless noted otherwise, quotes are for a full-coverage policy for a 30-year-old man with good credit and a clean driving record who drives a 2015 Honda Civic EX.

Minimum-liability policies provide liability coverage with the state’s required minimum limits.

Full-coverage policies include collision, comprehensive and liability coverage:

  • Bodily injury liability: $50,000 per person, $100,000 per accident
  • Property damage liability: $25,000
  • Uninsured/underinsured motorist bodily injury: $50,000 per person and $100,000 per accident
  • Personal injury protection: minimum limits, where required by law
  • Collision: $500 deductible
  • Comprehensive: $500 deductible


Our team of insurance experts rated insurance companies based on several categories. These categories include average rates, discounts, coverage options, third-party customer service ratings and app/website experience. We weighted these categories based on what customers value in an insurance company.

For third-party customer service ratings, we included NAIC’s Complaint Index scores and financial strength ratings from A.M. Best. NAIC Complaint Index scores are used to determine how satisfied customers are with their claims, while financial strength ratings from A.M. Best reflect the ability to pay out claims. Overall satisfaction ratings are from the J.D. Power 2024 U.S. Auto Insurance Study.

*USAA is only available to current and former members of the military as well as certain family members.