Best Homeowners Insurance in Kansas

How Does LendingTree Get Paid?

Top Kansas home insurance companies

Cheapest homeowners insurance in Kansas: Shelter

Shelter has the cheapest homeowners insurance in Kansas at $3,227 a year, or $269 a month. This is 19% less than the next-cheapest rate of $330 a month from Marysville Mutual. It’s also 40% less than the state average of $451 a month.

Cheapest homeowners insurance in Kansas.

Home insurance rates by company

CompanyAnnual rateLendingTree score
ShelterShelter$3,2274.5 stars
Marysville MutualMarysville Mutual$3,9603 stars
Travelers logoTravelers$4,4163.5-Stars
State Farm logoState Farm$4,6264-Stars
Allstate logoAllstate$5,1304-Stars
Farm BureauFarm Bureau$5,3913.5-Stars
American FamilyAmerican Family$7,2104-Stars
nationwide logoNationwide$9,3353.5-Stars
Average rates are based on a policy with $400,000 of dwelling coverage and $200,000 of personal property coverage.

Best Kansas home insurance companies

Cheap rates and good customer service help make Shelter the best home insurance company overall in Kansas. State Farm has the best shopping experience, while Allstate offers the best coverage features.

CompanyBest forAnnual rateCustomer satisfaction*Complaint rating**
ShelterOverall$3,227Not rated0.3
State FarmShopping experience$4,6266431.05
AllstateCoverage features$5,1306311.3
*Source: J.D. Power 2024 U.S. Home Insurance Study. Higher is better; 640 is average.

**Source: National Association of Insurance Commissioners. Lower is better; 1.0 is average

Best home insurance company overall: Shelter

Shelter

Annual rate: $3,227

4.5 Stars

Along with low rates, Shelter has an excellent complaint rating from the National Association of Insurance Commissioners (NAIC). Its 0.3 score means it has about one-third as many complaints as average.

Shelter offers valuable add-ons as well as all the standard home insurance protections , too. These include protections from sewer and drain backups and coverage for some home business and farming activities.

PROS

  • Cheapest average rates in Kansas
  • Excellent complaint rating
  • Add-ons for some home businesses and farming

CONS

  • Instant quotes not available online

Best shopping experience: State Farm

State Farm

Annual rate: $4,626

4-Stars

State Farm complements personalized services from its agents with a convenient online shopping platform. Its website can give you a home insurance quote in minutes. It also connects you to an agent for more help.

The company’s rates are cheaper than average, and it has good customer service scores. This includes a customer satisfaction rating from J.D. Power that’s better than average.

PROS

  • Rates are 15% less than the state average
  • Good customer satisfaction score
  • User-friendly website for instant quotes
  • Personalized service from local agents

CONS

  • A few other companies have lower rates

Best policy features: Allstate

Allstate

Annual rate: $5,130

4-Stars

Allstate offers policy features that can save you money down the line. For example, its Deductible Rewards program lowers your deductible at no extra cost when you avoid claims. Its Claim RateGuard feature protects you from a rate increase if you do have a claim.

Like other large companies, Allstate offers instant quotes online. This makes it easy to compare Allstate’s rates to the quotes you get from other companies.

PROS

  • Rates are cheaper than average
  • Policy features can save you money in the future
  • Widespread agent network for personalized service

CONS

  • Customer service scores are worse than average
  • Rates are only 5% less than state average

How much is homeowners insurance in Kansas?

The average cost of homeowners insurance in Kansas is $5,412 a year for a typical home. This works out to $451 a month.

The actual price you pay depends on factors like:

  • Your home’s age and construction features
  • The home’s location
  • Your insurance history and credit
  • Any discounts you may receive

Each company weighs these factors differently. This makes it good to compare home insurance quotes from a few different companies when you buy or renew your policy.

Home insurance rates by coverage amount

Your policy’s dwelling limit has a big impact on your homeowners insurance rate. For example, a policy with a $450,000 dwelling limit costs 25% more than a $350,000 policy.

Home insurance costs by dwelling limit

Dwelling limitAnnual rate
$350,000$4,825
$400,000$5,412
$450,000$6,029

If you have a mortgage, your lender will make you insure your home at its replacement value . You can choose a lower dwelling limit if you have a low loan balance or no mortgage at all. However, doing so can leave you short on insurance funds to rebuild, if a major disaster strikes.

Kansas home insurance rates by city

At $4,384 a year, Baldwin City has the cheapest home insurance among Kansas’ cities and towns. Homeowners in Beeler have the most expensive home insurance at $6,721 a year.

Home insurance costs an average of $4,669 a year in Kansas City, or $389 a month. This is 14% less than the state average. Topeka homeowners pay an average of $414 a month, or 8% less than the average.

Home insurance rates near you

CityAnnual rate Difference from state average
Abbyville$6,08812%
Abilene$5,046-7%
Admire$4,946-9%
Agenda$4,846-10%
Agra$5,9029%
Albert$6,62022%
Alden$5,5903%
Alexander$6,51120%
Allen$4,902-9%
Alma$4,945-9%
Almena$5,96610%
Alta Vista$4,995-8%
Altamont$5,016-7%
Alton$6,07512%
Altoona$5,256-3%
Americus$4,942-9%
Andale$6,31717%
Andover$6,16114%
Anthony$5,97410%
Arcadia$4,880-10%
Argonia$6,17214%
Arkansas City$5,93410%
Arlington$6,05412%
Arma$4,898-9%
Arnold$6,24315%
Ashland$6,18614%
Assaria$5,3870%
Atchison$4,577-15%
Athol$6,04112%
Atlanta$6,17314%
Attica$6,07412%
Atwood$5,5292%
Auburn$4,868-10%
Augusta$6,13113%
Aurora$4,962-8%
Axtell$4,707-13%
Baileyville$4,735-13%
Baldwin City$4,384-19%
Barnard$5,292-2%
Barnes$5,064-6%
Bartlett$5,000-8%
Basehor$4,578-15%
Baxter Springs$5,130-5%
Bazine$6,31417%
Beattie$4,884-10%
Beaumont$6,16014%
Beeler$6,72124%
Bel Aire$6,30216%
Belle Plaine$6,11913%
Belleville$4,889-10%
Beloit$5,051-7%
Belpre$6,48320%
Belvue$4,787-12%
Bendena$4,584-15%
Benedict$5,285-2%
Bennington$5,4471%
Bentley$6,33217%
Benton$6,15314%
Bern$4,618-15%
Berryton$4,885-10%
Beverly$5,235-3%
Bird City$5,5773%
Bison$6,31817%
Blue Mound$4,811-11%
Blue Rapids$5,025-7%
Bluff City$5,8949%
Bogue$6,39018%
Bonner Springs$4,633-14%
Bremen$4,839-11%
Brewster$5,8478%
Bronson$5,048-7%
Brookville$5,299-2%
Brownell$6,60522%
Bucklin$6,19114%
Bucyrus$4,686-13%
Buffalo$5,256-3%
Buhler$6,06312%
Bunker Hill$6,61822%
Burden$6,01611%
Burdett$6,24915%
Burdick$4,987-8%
Burlingame$4,931-9%
Burlington$5,102-6%
Burns$5,5913%
Burr Oak$5,028-7%
Burrton$5,93610%
Bushton$5,379-1%
Byers$6,42019%
Caldwell$6,01211%
Cambridge$6,05412%
Caney$5,4120%
Canton$5,5372%
Carbondale$4,911-9%
Cassoday$6,04412%
Catharine$6,52921%
Cawker City$4,951-9%
Cedar$6,06112%
Cedar Point$4,974-8%
Cedar Vale$5,4952%
Centerville$4,882-10%
Centralia$4,665-14%
Chanute$4,947-9%
Chapman$4,997-8%
Chase$5,6084%
Chautauqua$5,5012%
Cheney$6,25916%
Cherokee$4,886-10%
Cherryvale$5,312-2%
Chetopa$4,991-8%
Chicopee$4,887-10%
Cimarron$6,19414%
Circleville$4,814-11%
Claflin$6,42819%
Clay Center$5,016-7%
Clayton$6,23815%
Clearview City$4,406-19%
Clearwater$6,45819%
Clifton$5,054-7%
Clyde$5,012-7%
Coats$6,52120%
Coffeyville$5,191-4%
Colby$5,6304%
Coldwater$6,26816%
Collyer$6,32417%
Colony$4,913-9%
Columbus$4,985-8%
Colwich$6,28316%
Concordia$5,044-7%
Conway Springs$6,14414%
Coolidge$5,8728%
Copeland$6,17514%
Corning$4,769-12%
Cottonwood Falls$4,982-8%
Council Grove$4,978-8%
Courtland$4,867-10%
Crestline$4,935-9%
Cuba$4,937-9%
Cummings$4,720-13%
Cunningham$6,02011%
Damar$6,30817%
Danville$6,26316%
De Soto$4,561-16%
Dearing$5,048-7%
Deerfield$6,15214%
Delia$4,844-10%
Delphos$5,4110%
Denison$4,852-10%
Dennis$5,059-7%
Denton$4,597-15%
Derby$6,19214%
Dexter$6,00311%
Dighton$5,97710%
Dodge City$6,17314%
Dorrance$6,31517%
Douglass$6,15414%
Downs$6,15514%
Dresden$6,05312%
Durham$5,153-5%
Dwight$4,958-8%
Eastborough$6,36518%
Easton$4,686-13%
Edgerton$4,445-18%
Edna$5,040-7%
Edson$6,02911%
Edwardsville$4,677-14%
Effingham$4,690-13%
El Dorado$6,00111%
Elbing$6,08412%
Elk City$5,4661%
Elk Falls$5,5853%
Elkhart$5,7857%
Ellinwood$6,42319%
Ellis$6,31417%
Ellsworth$5,6204%
Elmdale$4,881-10%
Elsmore$4,967-8%
Elwood$4,597-15%
Emmett$4,868-10%
Emporia$5,015-7%
Englewood$6,13513%
Ensign$6,36118%
Enterprise$4,943-9%
Erie$5,017-7%
Esbon$4,970-8%
Eskridge$4,894-10%
Eudora$4,449-18%
Eureka$5,4691%
Everest$4,575-15%
Fairview$4,558-16%
Fairway$4,422-18%
Fall River$5,4431%
Falun$5,4401%
Farlington$4,892-10%
Florence$5,274-3%
Fontana$4,800-11%
Ford$6,30216%
Formoso$5,002-8%
Fort Dodge$6,38518%
Fort Leavenworth$4,569-16%
Fort Riley$4,904-9%
Fort Scott$4,993-8%
Fostoria$5,289-2%
Fowler$6,02811%
Frankfort$5,018-7%
Franklin$4,811-11%
Fredonia$5,327-2%
Freeport$6,21415%
Frontenac$4,877-10%
Fulton$4,970-8%
Galena$4,913-9%
Galesburg$4,960-8%
Galva$5,5883%
Garden City$6,06212%
Garden Plain$6,33117%
Gardner$4,429-18%
Garfield$6,44219%
Garland$4,926-9%
Garnett$4,905-9%
Gas$5,058-7%
Gaylord$6,06312%
Gem$5,7847%
Geneseo$5,6534%
Geuda Springs$6,03712%
Girard$4,921-9%
Glade$6,00911%
Glasco$5,092-6%
Glen Elder$5,042-7%
Goddard$6,38518%
Goessel$5,118-5%
Goff$4,843-11%
Goodland$5,6504%
Gorham$6,39118%
Gove$6,03011%
Grainfield$6,03712%
Grandview Plaza$4,822-11%
Grantville$4,674-14%
Great Bend$6,39618%
Greeley$4,945-9%
Green$4,918-9%
Greenleaf$5,046-7%
Greensburg$6,22915%
Greenwich$6,28016%
Grenola$5,5903%
Gridley$5,086-6%
Grinnell$5,7156%
Gypsum$5,214-4%
Haddam$4,980-8%
Halstead$5,93310%
Hamilton$5,354-1%
Hanover$4,969-8%
Hanston$6,29216%
Hardtner$6,48820%
Harper$6,10313%
Hartford$4,979-8%
Harveyville$4,891-10%
Havana$5,4030%
Haven$6,10813%
Havensville$4,912-9%
Haviland$6,33717%
Hays$6,31117%
Haysville$6,30016%
Hazelton$6,23315%
Healy$5,94810%
Hepler$4,980-8%
Herington$4,994-8%
Herndon$5,8959%
Hesston$5,8358%
Hiawatha$4,569-16%
Highland$4,573-15%
Hill City$6,23415%
Hillsboro$5,128-5%
Hillsdale$5,255-3%
Hoisington$6,45619%
Holcomb$5,95710%
Hollenberg$4,850-10%
Holton$4,803-11%
Holyrood$5,4711%
Home$5,055-7%
Hope$5,006-8%
Horton$4,646-14%
Howard$5,5873%
Hoxie$5,8969%
Hoyt$4,829-11%
Hudson$6,58022%
Hugoton$5,8668%
Humboldt$5,018-7%
Hunter$5,089-6%
Hutchinson$6,04012%
Independence$5,350-1%
Ingalls$6,16914%
Inman$5,6565%
Iola$5,050-7%
Isabel$6,38418%
Iuka$6,47920%
Jamestown$5,138-5%
Jennings$6,08612%
Jetmore$6,18214%
Jewell$5,055-7%
Johnson City$5,7857%
Junction City$4,820-11%
Kanopolis$5,6124%
Kanorado$5,7767%
Kansas City$4,669-14%
Kechi$6,23315%
Kendall$5,94310%
Kensington$5,98010%
Kincaid$4,899-9%
Kingman$6,08012%
Kinsley$6,02211%
Kiowa$6,31517%
Kirwin$5,94910%
Kismet$6,05212%
La Crosse$6,31317%
La Harpe$4,974-8%
Lacygne$4,818-11%
Lake City$6,34717%
Lake Quivira$4,516-17%
Lakin$5,8899%
Lamont$5,8578%
Lancaster$4,621-15%
Lane$4,824-11%
Lansing$4,462-18%
Larned$6,20015%
Latham$6,06312%
Lawrence$4,414-18%
Le Roy$5,036-7%
Leavenworth$4,578-15%
Leawood$4,457-18%
Lebanon$6,21615%
Lebo$5,108-6%
Lecompton$4,427-18%
Lehigh$5,196-4%
Lenexa$4,457-18%
Lenora$6,13213%
Leon$5,97910%
Leonardville$4,978-8%
Leoti$5,7707%
Levant$5,6885%
Lewis$6,06512%
Liberal$5,99911%
Liberty$5,294-2%
Liebenthal$6,47420%
Lincoln$5,360-1%
Lincoln Center$5,360-1%
Lincolnville$5,261-3%
Lindsborg$5,5312%
Linn$5,027-7%
Linwood$4,529-16%
Little River$5,5422%
Logan$5,9229%
Long Island$5,93910%
Longford$4,880-10%
Longton$5,5362%
Lorraine$5,5523%
Lost Springs$5,091-6%
Louisburg$4,692-13%
Lucas$6,58722%
Ludell$5,8638%
Luray$6,04812%
Lyndon$4,901-9%
Lyons$5,5903%
Macksville$6,34717%
Madison$5,379-1%
Mahaska$4,959-8%
Maize$6,23915%
Manhattan$4,956-8%
Mankato$5,028-7%
Manter$6,00111%
Maple City$5,7707%
Maple Hill$4,921-9%
Mapleton$5,055-7%
Marienthal$6,01011%
Marion$5,259-3%
Marquette$5,6775%
Marysville$4,984-8%
Matfield Green$5,035-7%
Mayetta$4,816-11%
Mayfield$6,13813%
Mc Cracken$6,45719%
Mc Cune$4,959-8%
Mc Donald$5,6394%
Mc Farland$4,882-10%
Mc Louth$4,571-16%
McConnell AFB$6,27016%
McPherson$5,6314%
Meade$5,99311%
Medicine Lodge$6,34017%
Melvern$4,961-8%
Meriden$4,659-14%
Merriam$4,528-16%
Milan$6,21815%
Milford$4,898-10%
Milton$6,23115%
Miltonvale$5,090-6%
Minneapolis$5,4541%
Minneola$6,17314%
Mission$4,486-17%
Mission Hills$4,426-18%
Moline$5,6124%
Montezuma$6,01011%
Monument$5,7747%
Moran$5,049-7%
Morganville$4,892-10%
Morland$6,32517%
Morrill$4,558-16%
Morrowville$4,865-10%
Moscow$6,11013%
Mound City$4,809-11%
Mound Valley$5,211-4%
Moundridge$5,6013%
Mount Hope$6,19014%
Mulberry$4,866-10%
Mullinville$6,32817%
Mulvane$6,12213%
Munden$4,952-9%
Murdock$6,00911%
Muscotah$4,688-13%
Narka$4,763-12%
Nashville$6,00311%
Natoma$6,09313%
Neal$5,5382%
Nekoma$6,53521%
Neodesha$5,4230%
Neosho Falls$5,023-7%
Neosho Rapids$4,845-10%
Ness City$6,33017%
Netawaka$4,675-14%
New Cambria$5,207-4%
New Century$4,523-16%
Newton$5,8238%
Nickerson$6,08512%
Niotaze$5,5913%
Norcatur$5,95010%
North Newton$5,8478%
Norton$5,99011%
Nortonville$4,565-16%
Norway$4,825-11%
Norwich$6,05012%
Oaklawn-Sunview$6,33717%
Oakley$5,7677%
Oberlin$5,96810%
Offerle$6,23115%
Ogallah$6,31017%
Ogden$4,948-9%
Oketo$4,871-10%
Olathe$4,460-18%
Olmitz$6,45619%
Olpe$4,965-8%
Olsburg$4,954-8%
Onaga$4,921-9%
Oneida$4,640-14%
Opolis$4,799-11%
Osage City$4,966-8%
Osawatomie$4,828-11%
Osborne$6,17414%
Oskaloosa$4,579-15%
Oswego$4,956-8%
Otis$6,45619%
Ottawa$4,816-11%
Overbrook$4,677-14%
Overland Park$4,480-17%
Oxford$6,04012%
Ozawkie$4,629-14%
Palco$6,30917%
Palmer$4,918-9%
Paola$4,718-13%
Paradise$6,28116%
Park$6,06812%
Park City$6,26416%
Parker$4,867-10%
Parkerfield$5,93510%
Parsons$5,054-7%
Partridge$6,02511%
Pawnee Rock$6,44019%
Paxico$4,893-10%
Peabody$5,136-5%
Peck$6,17614%
Penokee$6,18814%
Perry$4,565-16%
Peru$5,5713%
Pfeifer$6,55821%
Phillipsburg$5,8759%
Piedmont$5,6374%
Pierceville$6,66423%
Piqua$5,119-5%
Pittsburg$4,848-10%
Plains$6,01911%
Plainville$5,97710%
Pleasanton$4,833-11%
Plevna$6,08512%
Pomona$4,813-11%
Portis$6,21715%
Potwin$6,01611%
Powhattan$4,557-16%
Prairie View$6,00911%
Prairie Village$4,413-18%
Pratt$6,30917%
Prescott$4,843-11%
Pretty Prairie$6,08012%
Princeton$4,864-10%
Protection$6,17214%
Quenemo$4,902-9%
Quinter$5,97410%
Ramona$5,046-7%
Randall$4,930-9%
Randolph$4,917-9%
Ransom$6,47120%
Rantoul$4,771-12%
Raymond$5,4681%
Reading$4,886-10%
Redfield$5,014-7%
Republic$4,827-11%
Rexford$5,6003%
Richfield$6,01111%
Richmond$4,856-10%
Riley$4,939-9%
Riverton$4,894-10%
Robinson$4,569-16%
Rock$6,10113%
Roeland Park$4,444-18%
Rolla$5,8238%
Rosalia$6,20615%
Rose Hill$6,23815%
Rossville$4,898-9%
Roxbury$5,4881%
Rozel$6,20115%
Rush Center$6,33617%
Russell$6,42019%
Sabetha$4,599-15%
Salina$5,237-3%
Satanta$6,01511%
Savonburg$5,078-6%
Sawyer$6,48420%
Scammon$4,984-8%
Scandia$4,935-9%
Schoenchen$6,56321%
Scott City$5,9149%
Scranton$4,899-9%
Sedan$5,5062%
Sedgwick$5,93510%
Selden$5,94210%
Seneca$4,653-14%
Severy$5,5563%
Sharon$6,42219%
Sharon Springs$5,5573%
Shawnee$4,468-17%
Silver Lake$4,895-10%
Simpson$5,104-6%
Smith Center$6,02811%
Soldier$4,912-9%
Solomon$5,077-6%
South Haven$6,00311%
South Hutchinson$6,05812%
Spearville$6,16714%
Spivey$6,15414%
Spring Hill$4,661-14%
St. Francis$5,6284%
St. George$4,900-9%
St. John$6,35517%
St. Marys$4,815-11%
St. Paul$5,038-7%
Stafford$6,33117%
Stark$5,080-6%
Sterling$5,5683%
Stilwell$4,544-16%
Stockton$5,95710%
Strong City$4,990-8%
Sublette$6,04212%
Summerfield$4,749-12%
Sun City$6,54621%
Sylvan Grove$5,4791%
Sylvia$6,07212%
Syracuse$5,6645%
Talmage$4,998-8%
Tampa$5,095-6%
Tecumseh$4,985-8%
Tescott$5,4160%
Thayer$4,991-8%
Tipton$4,981-8%
Tonganoxie$4,672-14%
Topeka$4,972-8%
Toronto$5,261-3%
Towanda$6,12513%
Treece$5,041-7%
Tribune$5,6214%
Troy$4,556-16%
Turon$6,02511%
Tyro$5,4300%
Udall$6,04512%
Ulysses$5,9109%
Uniontown$4,971-8%
Utica$6,41819%
Valley Center$6,21315%
Valley Falls$4,529-16%
Vassar$4,877-10%
Vermillion$4,742-12%
Victoria$6,25416%
Viola$6,37118%
Virgil$5,4791%
Wakarusa$4,903-9%
Wakeeney$6,26816%
Wakefield$5,017-7%
Waldo$6,32217%
Waldron$6,01611%
Walker$6,47620%
Wallace$5,8819%
Walnut$4,990-8%
Walton$5,8208%
Wamego$4,915-9%
Washington$5,029-7%
Waterville$5,017-7%
Wathena$4,568-16%
Waverly$4,974-8%
Webber$4,991-8%
Weir$4,915-9%
Welda$4,865-10%
Wellington$6,08312%
Wellsville$4,740-12%
Weskan$5,9199%
West Mineral$4,961-8%
Westmoreland$4,931-9%
Westphalia$4,822-11%
Westwood$4,440-18%
Westwood Hills$4,439-18%
Wetmore$4,607-15%
White City$4,955-8%
White Cloud$4,557-16%
Whitewater$6,01911%
Whiting$4,656-14%
Wichita$6,35217%
Williamsburg$4,877-10%
Wilmore$6,34817%
Wilsey$4,880-10%
Wilson$5,4841%
Winchester$4,595-15%
Windom$5,5983%
Winfield$5,97910%
Winona$5,6003%
Woodbine$4,948-9%
Woodston$6,03812%
Wright$6,42619%
Yates Center$5,208-4%
Zenda$6,13413%

Does Kansas homeowners insurance cover tornadoes?

Standard Kansas homeowners insurance typically covers damage from tornadoes and hailstorms. However, you may have a separate deductible for wind damage than you do for other covered perils or hazards.

  • Wind and hail deductibles are often offered as a percentage of your policy’s dwelling limit. If you choose a $300,000 dwelling limit with a 5% deductible, for example, you must pay the first $15,000 in wind damage repairs.
  • The deductible for other perils is usually offered in a flat dollar amount, often between about $500 and $2,500.
  • Wind deductibles tend to be higher than the deductible for other perils.
  • Choosing higher deductibles lowers your rate. They also require you to spend more of your own money to rebuild after a disaster.

Flood insurance protection for Kansas homes

Kansas homeowners insurance does not cover flood damage. However, you can buy a separate flood insurance policy for protection from this risk.

If you have a mortgage and live in a high-risk flood zone, your lender will make you get flood insurance. But the coverage is optional if you don’t have a mortgage or live in a low- or moderate-risk area. You can find a home’s flood risk on the Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA) website.

Most flood insurance is bought through the FEMA-managed National Flood Insurance Program (NFIP). The average NFIP flood insurance cost in Kansas is $971 a year, or about $81 a month.

A few private companies also offer flood insurance. Some private flood insurance companies offer more coverage than NFIP. Unless you are buying flood insurance to close a loan, you have to wait 30 days for the coverage to kick in. Private flood insurance often has shorter waiting periods.

Most local home insurance agents can help you get flood insurance quotes. Start with your current agent, or speak with companies you contacted for home insurance quotes.

Methodology

The rates shown in this article are based on non-binding quotes collected from Quadrant Information Services. Your rates may vary. Average rates were compiled from rates in Kansas. The following coverages and deductible were used unless otherwise noted:

  • $400,000 dwelling coverage
  • $40,000 other structures
  • $200,000 personal property
  • $80,000 loss of use coverage
  • $100,000 liability
  • $5,000 medical payments
  • $1,000 deductible

Our team of insurance experts rated insurance companies based on several categories. These categories include average rates, discounts, coverage options, third-party customer service ratings and app/website experience. We weighted these categories based on what customers value in an insurance company.

For third-party customer service ratings, we included complaint index scores from the National Association of Insurance Commissioners (NAIC) and financial strength ratings from AM Best. NAIC complaint index scores are used to determine how satisfied customers are with their claims, while financial strength ratings from AM Best reflect the ability to pay out claims.