Best Home Insurance in Nebraska 2026

State Farm is our pick for Nebraska home insurance overall, but Allstate may have better coverage

How Does LendingTree Get Paid?
Key takeaways
  • State Farm is the best homeowners insurance in Nebraska thanks to its cheap rates and solid coverage options.
  • Home insurance in Nebraska costs an average of $5,519 per year, which is more than double the national average.
  • Nebraska is part of “Tornado Alley,” so its homes are vulnerable to wind, hail and storm damage. This is largely why home insurance rates are so high in the state.

Best homeowners insurance in Nebraska

Choosing the best homeowners insurance isn’t just about finding the provider with the lowest premiums. You also want a policy that provides the right level of protection for your home with the coverages that make the most sense for you. 

We compared Nebraska insurers on a variety of factors including their average rates, coverage options, discounts and customer satisfaction. For having the lowest cost insurance in the state and a solid selection of coverage options, State Farm is our choice for best overall home insurance in Nebraska. But other insurance companies came out ahead based on other factors that might also be meaningful for you.

Best overall: State Farm

State Farm

Average annual rate: $3,406

4-Stars

Why we chose it: State Farm has the lowest average home insurance rates in Nebraska, across all dwelling coverage limits, and offers a range of coverage options that should satisfy most homeowners. In our study, the company earned high marks for website and app usability.

State Farm, which is the largest insurer in the nation, also got an above-average customer satisfaction rating in JD Power’s 2025 U.S. Home Insurance Study, though the National Association of Insurance Commissioners (NAIC) found that it got close to 40% more customer complaints last year than other companies its size. 

Who it’s best for: State Farm is best for Nebraska homeowners seeking the most affordable coverage in a high-cost state.

PROS

  • Most affordable average rates in the state
  • Large network of offices and agents
  • Financially strong 

CONS

  • Higher-than-average number of customer complaints 
  • Fewer discounts than some competitors

Best for coverage options: Allstate

Allstate

Average annual rate: $5,146

4-Stars

Why we chose it: Allstate has the third lowest rates in Nebraska and stands out for its distinct collection of coverage options. Some unique ones include coverage for electronic data recovery, energy-efficient upgrades, yard and garden, and sports equipment. People with home-based businesses can also get business property coverage.

Who it’s best for: Allstate is best for homeowners looking for a few more personalized coverages from a reputable insurer.

PROS

  • Great collection of coverage options for better personalization
  • User-friendly app and website
  • Good number of discount opportunities

CONS

  • Higher-than-average number of customer complaints
  • About half of claims are denied 

Best for customer service: American Family

American Family

Average annual rate: $5,294

4-Stars

Why we chose it: American Family gets about 60% fewer customer complaints than other companies its size, according to the NAIC. That’s one of the best ratings in the state. It also ranks above average in customer satisfaction in the J.D. Power 2025 U.S. Home Insurance Study. 

Who it’s best for: American Family is best for homeowners who value friendly and supportive customer service and are willing to pay a bit more for it. At least three Nebraska insurance companies offer less expensive average rates than American Family.

PROS

  • One of the lowest complaint ratings in the state
  • Well-rated app and website usability 

CONS

  • Fewer coverage options than some competitors
  • Financial strength not as robust some competitors

Best for military families: USAA

USAA

Average annual rate: $4,193

4-Stars

Why we chose it: More than 145,800 Nebraskans are veterans, active-duty servicemembers or National Guard members. For these families, USAA is an excellent home insurance option since it offers lower-than-average rates with benefits specific to military personnel. These include no deductible for uniform coverage, protections for military equipment and a deductible waiver for personal property damaged or lost in war. ‍ ‍

Who it’s best for: USAA is best for families and individuals seeking a military-friendly home insurance option.

PROS

  • Half as many customer complaints as average
  • Lower-than-average rates
  • Financially strong

CONS

  • Limited coverage options 
  • Only USAA members can open a policy

Compare home insurance rates and ratings in Nebraska

CompanyAverage annual rate*LendingTree rating Complaint rating*
State Farm$3,4064-Stars
4/5
1.4
Nationwide$4,9793.5-Stars
3.5/5
1.2
Allstate$5,1464-Stars
4/5
1.2
<American Family$5,2944-Stars
4/5
0.4
Farmers$6,0403.5-Stars
3.5/5
0.7
Farm Bureau$9,5773.5-Stars
3.5/5
0.6
USAA*$4,1934-Stars
4/5
0.5
*Premiums are a statewide average based on $400,000 of coverage. Complaint ratings are from the National Association of Insurance Commissioners (NAIC), based on the 2025 Complaint Index. A lower score is better. A score of 1.0 is average for a company of that size.

In Nebraska, rates can vary significantly between insurers. Comparing multiple options can help you find better pricing and coverage.

LendingTree analyzed home insurance quotes from every Nebraska ZIP code to identify the best options for you.

Our team evaluated pricing, customer experience, financial reliability and coverage features to determine the top home insurance companies in your state.

See our full methodology.

How much is homeowners insurance in Nebraska?

ne-home-26

The average annual cost of home insurance in Nebraska for a $400,000 property is $5,519, or $460 per month. That is more than twice the national average of $2,628.

Nebraska consistently has one of the highest numbers of home insurance claims by dollar amount in the country, according to the 2025 LexisNexis U.S. Home Trends Report. 

That’s because the state faces a range of seasonal disasters including tornadoes, wind and hail storms. Hail in Nebraska can get as large as baseballs, which can damage shingles and break windows. 

All of this, plus rising construction costs, have made insurance rates in the state the second highest in the country, just behind Oklahoma ($5,533).

Average home insurance rates by dwelling coverage amount

When comparing home insurance premiums, the cost can vary based on various factors, including the amount of coverage for your dwelling. 

Company$300,000 coverage$400,000 coverage$550,000 coverage$750,000 coverage
State Farm$2,889$3,406$4,195$5,066
USAA$3,413$4,193$5,138$5,771
Allstate$4,595$5,146$5,764$6,604
American Family$3,901$5,294$7,321$9,441
State average$4,392$5,519$7,142$9,083

Home insurance rates in Nebraska by city

Home insurance rates for $400,000 in dwelling coverage range from $4,903 to $6,549 in Nebraska cities and towns. The differences mostly come down to geography and weather.

The most expensive insurance rates are found in Superior, Red Cloud and Fairfield. These cities are all in the southern part of the state, which is part of “Hail Alley.” Being in a hail-prone area typically means roofs need to be replaced more often, which is a key factor for driving up insurance rates.

Springview, Niobrara, and Bristow have the lowest rates in the state. These are all small, rural villages located near the South Dakota border, where property values and rebuilding costs are lower compared to other parts of the state.

CityAverage rate
Abie$5,484
Albion$5,557
Alda$5,863
Alexandria$5,619
Allen$5,150
Alliance$5,629
Alvo$5,302
Amelia$5,142
Ames$5,531
Amherst$6,127
Angora$5,548
Anselmo$6,122
Ansley$6,237
Arapahoe$5,990
Arcadia$6,131
Archer$5,845
Arlington$5,481
Ashby$5,327
Ashland$5,522
Ashton$5,675
Atkinson$5,342
Atlanta$6,100
Auburn$5,054
Aurora$6,410
Axtell$6,353
Ayr$6,467
Barneston$5,419
Bartlett$5,303
Bartley$6,167
Bassett$5,179
Battle Creek$5,530
Bayard$5,774
Beatrice$5,276
Beaver Crossing$5,643
Bee$5,422
Beemer$5,363
Belden$5,228
Belgrade$5,930
Bellevue$5,052
Bellwood$5,362
Belvidere$5,616
Benedict$5,601
Benkelman$5,976
Bennet$5,274
Bennington$5,619
Bertrand$6,116
Bingham$5,579
Bladen$6,169
Blair$5,489
Bloomfield$5,016
Bloomington$6,050
Blue Hill$6,406
Blue Springs$5,490
Boelus$5,766
Boys Town$5,866
Bradshaw$6,133
Brady$5,864
Brainard$5,585
Brewster$5,676
Bridgeport$5,675
Bristow$4,952
Broadwater$5,579
Brock$5,083
Broken Bow$6,365
Brule$5,892
Bruno$5,525
Brunswick$5,216
Burchard$5,332
Burr$5,208
Burwell$5,923
Bushnell$5,589
Butte$5,010
Byron$5,727
Cairo$5,765
Callaway$5,786
Cambridge$6,009
Campbell$6,079
Carleton$5,732
Carroll$5,212
Cedar Bluffs$5,644
Cedar Creek$5,587
Cedar Rapids$5,586
Center$5,083
Central City$5,978
Ceresco$5,462
Chadron$5,567
Chambers$5,289
Champion$6,046
Chappell$5,877
Chester$5,646
Clarks$5,980
Clarkson$5,516
Clatonia$5,827
Clay Center$6,390
Coleridge$5,092
Colon$5,630
Columbus$5,293
Comstock$5,988
Cook$5,258
Cordova$5,675
Cortland$5,870
Cozad$5,718
Crab Orchard$5,371
Crawford$5,472
Creston$5,558
Crete$5,627
Crofton$4,994
Crookston$5,228
Culbertson$6,038
Curtis$5,953
Dakota City$5,009
Dalton$5,571
Danbury$6,146
Davenport$5,644
Davey$5,104
David City$5,578
Dawson$5,125
Daykin$5,568
De Witt$5,680
Deweese$6,252
Dickens$5,844
Diller$5,416
Dix$5,737
Dixon$5,273
Dodge$5,404
Douglas$5,354
Du Bois$5,119
Dunbar$5,230
Duncan$5,492
Dunning$5,709
Dwight$5,528
Eagle$5,279
Eddyville$6,078
Edison$5,894
Elgin$5,433
Elk Creek$5,207
Ellsworth$5,470
Elm Creek$6,157
Elmwood$5,264
Elsie$5,802
Elsmere$5,304
Elwood$5,815
Elyria$5,820
Emerson$5,096
Emmet$5,057
Enders$6,124
Ericson$5,933
Eustis$5,855
Ewing$5,322
Exeter$5,863
Fairbury$5,479
Fairfield$6,523
Fairmont$5,718
Falls City$5,144
Farnam$5,741
Farwell$5,764
Firth$5,430
Fontanelle$5,630
Fordyce$5,006
Fort Calhoun$5,503
Franklin$6,119
Fremont$5,445
Friend$5,802
Fullerton$5,950
Funk$6,246
Garland$5,468
Geneva$5,742
Genoa$5,596
Gering$5,845
Gibbon$5,968
Gilead$5,520
Giltner$6,480
Glenvil$6,232
Goehner$5,597
Gordon$5,335
Gothenburg$5,828
Grafton$5,647
Grand Island$6,008
Grant$5,681
Greeley$5,805
Greenwood$5,335
Gresham$5,617
Gretna$5,248
Gross$4,952
Guide Rock$6,262
Hadar$5,344
Haigler$5,815
Hallam$5,583
Halsey$5,592
Hampton$6,356
Hardy$6,225
Harrisburg$5,685
Harrison$5,517
Hartington$5,052
Hastings$6,017
Hay Springs$5,528
Hazard$5,695
Heartwell$6,260
Hebron$5,778
Hemingford$5,604
Henderson$5,871
Hendley$5,835
Herman$5,497
Hershey$5,874
Hickman$5,433
Hildreth$6,136
Holbrook$5,757
Holdrege$6,209
Holstein$6,305
Homer$5,224
Hooper$5,690
Hordville$6,162
Howells$5,511
Hubbard$5,133
Hubbell$5,514
Humboldt$5,193
Humphrey$5,593
Huntley$6,256
Imperial$6,196
Inavale$6,242
Indianola$6,134
Inland$6,060
Inman$5,093
Ithaca$5,679
Jackson$5,136
Jansen$5,345
Johnson$5,193
Johnstown$4,995
Julian$5,198
Juniata$6,061
Kearney$5,990
Kennard$5,516
Keystone$5,532
Kilgore$5,186
Kimball$5,896
La Vista$5,021
Lakeside$5,550
Lamar$6,036
Laurel$5,143
Lawrence$6,351
Lebanon$6,017
Leigh$5,542
Lemoyne$5,383
Lewellen$5,705
Lewiston$5,324
Lexington$5,610
Liberty$5,337
Lincoln$5,058
Lindsay$5,609
Linwood$5,486
Lisco$5,717
Litchfield$5,915
Long Pine$5,094
Loomis$6,164
Lorton$5,225
Louisville$5,260
Loup City$6,202
Lyman$5,679
Lynch$5,020
Lyons$5,269
Macy$5,263
Madison$5,460
Madrid$5,775
Magnet$5,225
Malcolm$5,320
Malmo$5,518
Manley$5,431
Marquette$6,340
Marsland$5,395
Martell$5,318
Maskell$5,023
Mason City$5,997
Max$5,814
Maywood$5,995
McCook$6,288
McCool Junction$5,890
McGrew$5,779
McLean$5,150
Mead$5,531
Meadow Grove$5,471
Melbeta$5,763
Memphis$5,616
Merna$6,005
Merriman$5,098
Milburn$6,122
Milford$5,524
Miller$6,307
Milligan$5,579
Mills$4,998
Minatare$5,799
Minden$6,446
Mitchell$5,779
Monowi$5,020
Monroe$5,746
Moorefield$5,872
Morrill$5,640
Morse Bluff$5,437
Murdock$5,349
Murray$5,129
Naper$5,035
Naponee$6,232
Nebraska City$5,151
Nehawka$5,061
Neligh$5,398
Nemaha$5,167
Nenzel$5,229
Newman Grove$5,562
Newport$5,112
Nickerson$5,630
Niobrara$4,903
Norfolk$5,405
North Bend$5,475
North Platte$5,687
O’Neill$5,059
Oak$6,152
Oakdale$5,369
Oakland$5,378
Oconto$6,201
Odell$5,522
Odessa$6,353
Offutt AFB$5,026
Ogallala$5,703
Ohiowa$5,696
Omaha$5,533
Ong$6,080
Orchard$5,131
Ord$6,099
Orleans$6,091
Osceola$6,036
Oshkosh$5,813
Osmond$5,253
Otoe$5,150
Oxford$6,009
Page$5,169
Palisade$6,161
Palmer$6,098
Palmyra$5,283
Panama$5,541
Papillion$5,020
Parks$5,842
Pawnee City$5,280
Pender$5,269
Peru$5,219
Petersburg$5,700
Phillips$6,206
Pickrell$5,643
Pierce$5,376
Pilger$5,527
Plainview$5,266
Platte Center$5,445
Plattsmouth$5,125
Pleasant Dale$5,356
Pleasanton$5,992
Plymouth$5,545
Polk$6,113
Ponca$5,146
Prague$5,407
Primrose$5,478
Purdum$5,685
Ragan$6,276
Ralston$5,404
Randolph$5,143
Ravenna$6,002
Raymond$5,382
Red Cloud$6,527
Republican City$6,259
Reynolds$5,417
Richfield$5,167
Rising City$5,637
Riverdale$6,048
Riverton$6,089
Roca$5,109
Rockville$5,785
Rogers$5,535
Rosalie$5,168
Royal$5,238
Rulo$5,161
Rushville$5,323
Ruskin$6,202
Salem$5,057
Sargent$6,196
Saronville$6,166
Schuyler$5,464
Scotia$5,830
Scottsbluff$5,973
Scribner$5,551
Seneca$5,416
Seward$5,592
Shelby$5,560
Shelton$5,970
Shickley$5,685
Shubert$5,130
Sidney$5,992
Smithfield$5,861
Snyder$5,410
South Sioux City$5,010
Sparks$5,236
Spencer$4,971
Sprague$5,463
Springfield$5,159
Springview$4,884
St Columbans$5,163
St. Edward$5,591
St. Helena$4,963
St. Paul$6,114
Stamford$6,095
Stanton$5,410
Staplehurst$5,514
Stapleton$5,561
Steele City$5,402
Steinauer$5,218
Stella$5,095
Stockville$5,969
Strang$5,652
Stratton$5,932
Stromsburg$5,542
Sumner$6,232
Superior$6,549
Surprise$5,549
Sutton$6,383
Swanton$5,612
Syracuse$5,117
Table Rock$5,192
Talmage$5,090
Taylor$5,868
Tecumseh$5,249
Tekamah$5,458
Terrytown$5,844
Thedford$5,564
Thurston$5,118
Tilden$5,419
Tobias$5,504
Trenton$6,044
Trumbull$6,430
Tryon$5,591
Uehling$5,384
Ulysses$5,549
Unadilla$5,196
Union$5,064
Upland$6,178
Utica$5,671
Valentine$5,282
Valley$5,917
Valparaiso$5,373
Venango$5,814
Verdigre$4,979
Verdon$5,069
Virginia$5,347
Wahoo$5,557
Wakefield$5,224
Wallace$6,063
Walthill$5,206
Walton$5,123
Washington$5,534
Waterbury$5,277
Wauneta$6,066
Wausa$5,033
Waverly$5,138
Wayne$5,281
Weeping Water$5,091
Wellfleet$5,876
West Point$5,368
Western$5,575
Westerville$6,053
Weston$5,495
Whiteclay$5,305
Whitman$5,242
Whitney$5,294
Wilcox$6,335
Willow Island$5,495
Wilsonville$5,789
Winnetoon$5,064
Winside$5,297
Winslow$5,523
Wisner$5,361
Wolbach$5,994
Wood Lake$5,245
Wood River$5,801
Woodland Park$5,419
Wymore$5,545
Wynot$5,051
York$5,772
Yutan$5,479

Current state of homeowners insurance in Nebraska

Nebraska homeowners face some of the nation’s highest home insurance costs thanks to its vulnerability to extreme weather events like tornadoes and hail storms. These weather conditions are the driving force behind Nebraska’s average annual home insurance cost, which is more than double the national rate. 

Nebraska homeowners have seen a 67.7% increase in average home insurance rates between 2021 and 2025, the the fifth biggest jump in the nation. It’s also higher than the national average increase of 47.9%. The biggest increase took place in 2024 (22.9%), which was also the same year in which 101 tornadoes hit the state.

As far as home size and age, Nebraska sits somewhere in the middle compared to other states. Nebraska homes are 45 years old on average, and 2,016 square feet. Keep in mind that home age and size play a large role when shopping for insurance rates and determining what type of coverage is best.

How to compare homeowners insurance in Nebraska

When comparing options, don’t just look at rates. You should also consider: 

  • Coverage limits: Make sure you choose enough coverage to pay for the cost of repairing or rebuilding your home after a disaster.
  • Deductibles: Higher deductibles can lower your monthly costs, but make sure you’ll have the cash on hand when you need to file a claim.
  • Exclusions: Be sure to check what isn’t covered (like floods), so there are no surprises when it comes time to file a claim.
  • Add-ons: Consider extra coverage for high-value items like jewelry or sporting equipment.

And if you own one or more vehicles, consider bundling your home and auto insurance. Many insurance companies offer big discounts for this.

How LendingTree helps you find the right policy

Shopping for home insurance isn’t always straightforward — especially when availability and pricing can vary widely. LendingTree makes it easier by helping you explore options from multiple insurers, so you can find coverage that fits your home, location and budget.

How it works

Tell us about your home

Answer a few quick questions about your home, location and coverage needs.

Compare options from insurers

See quotes and typical rates from insurers that offer coverage in your area.

Choose the right policy

Review your options and pick the coverage that fits your needs and budget.

Frequently asked questions

Homeowners insurance is not a state requirement in Nebraska. However, the majority of mortgage lenders do require homeowners to have a property insurance policy for the duration of their home loan.

The average homeowners insurance policy in Nebraska is $5,519, which is more than double the national average of $2,628. Nebraska has expensive insurance because the state is particularly vulnerable to catastrophic events like tornadoes and hail storms. Extreme weather patterns over the last few years are a likely cause of Nebraska policies increasing by nearly 68% from 2021 to 2025 — the fifth largest increase in the nation.

Nebraska is not one of the states that offers a Fair Access to Insurance Requirements (FAIR) plan. FAIR plans are state-managed insurance plans designed to give an insurance option to homeowners who are otherwise unable to find coverage. If you’re having trouble finding a company that will sell you home insurance, talk with an independent agent who may be able to connect you with an insurer who specializes in high-risk coverage.

Nebraska is part of Tornado Alley, so worries about tornado damage to homes are real. The good news is that tornadoes are considered windstorm events, and most home insurance policies include coverage for wind damage. But if you’re in a high-risk area, be sure to choose a deductible you would be able to pay. Then talk to an agent to see if there are any coverage limits should a tornado cause major damage to your home.

Methodology

How we chose the best homeowners insurance in Nebraska

The rates shown in this article are based on an analysis of non-binding quotes obtained in February 2026 from Quadrant Information Services for sample homes in every Nebraska ZIP code. Unless otherwise noted, policies include:

  • Dwelling coverage: $400,000
  • Other structures: $40,000
  • Personal property: $200,000
  • Loss of use: $80,000
  • Personal liability: $100,000
  • Guest medical payments: $5,000
  • Deductible: $1,000

How we create LendingTree ratings

Our team of insurance experts evaluates insurance companies across several categories, including average rates, discounts, coverage options, third-party customer service ratings and app/website experience. We use this information to create LendingTree ratings, which help us identify and recommend the best insurance companies for consumers.

For third-party customer service ratings, we included NAIC’s Complaint Index scores and financial strength ratings from AM Best. NAIC Complaint Index scores are used to determine how satisfied customers are with their claims, while financial strength ratings from AM Best reflect the ability to pay out claims.

See our home insurance ratings methodology and full editorial guidelines for further details.

*USAA is only available to current and former members of the military, spouses and children of USAA members and employees of certain federal agencies.